Read Also:
- Lessons not learnt, Editorial
- Grading the grades, Sahina Shrestha
- Teaching teachers, Shreejana Shrestha
- A model government school, Shreejana Shrestha
Madan Ashrit Lower Secondary School of Sabaila village in Dhanusa district is now facing the most serious crisis in its history: infrastructure expansion has stalled, teachers are scarce and students are leaving in droves.
Over 50 students migrated to private schools in 2015, and more are expected to leave this year. The school has been without a management committee after two villagers were shot dead in a clash between rival political groups last year.
Established in 1996, the school receives an annual grant of Rs 1.2 million from the government. Local politicians wanted to control the budget with their own candidate to head the school management committee (SMC). The Nepali Congress and the Maoists formed an alliance against the UML. A gang — allegedly mobilised by former UML legislator Yoga Narayan Yadav — attacked the NC-Maoist supporters, killing two. Yadav is now facing trial.
“After this tragic incident, we do not have the courage to conduct another election to form a new committee,” says Headmaster Ram Pukar Gami, “and without it we will not be able to overcome this crisis.”
Since 2011, six persons have been killed in clashes over the SMCs in Dhanusa alone. Three more were killed in Rautahat in the same period, in disputes over control of school budgets. Disagreements and violence have disrupted SMC elections in more than 5,000 schools, mostly in the Tarai.
Krishna Thapa, President of the School Management Committee Federation, says: “In the absence of local elections, school management committees have become a platform for local politicians to flex their muscles.”
In general, schools run by democratically elected and functioning management committees that include parents perform better. But this still means politicians who want to control school funds choose poor and pliable parents as members, and purloin the school budget.
Parliament passed a much-delayed bill to amend the Education Act 1971 last month, dismissing provisions to elect heads to SMCs. Education Minister Giriraj Mani Pokharel told us this week: “There will be no more disputes and violence, because we did away with school management committee elections.”
The provision to allow only parents to head the committees has also been scrapped, and Krishna Thapa says this will undermine efforts to improve education: “Now those driven by ulterior motives will be heading the committees.”
Experts say allowing politically influential people — whose children are themselves in private schools or abroad — to oversee the running of government schools proves that the amendment to the Education Act was passed because of political pressure.
Rajendra Dahal, editor of the education magazine Sikshak, says: “This is a lost opportunity.”
The amended Act also allows over 17,000 temporary teachers to become permanent teachers. Those who are not confident that they will become permanent through an internal competition can opt for golden handshakes.
Lawmaker Radheshyam Adhikari of the opposition NC argues that unqualified and under-motivated teachers is a factor in the low quality of public education and Nepal has wasted a chance to hire young and qualified teachers, by retaining the old and exhausted ones.
