The debate about ‘Foreign Aid’ continues as we try to analyse if overseas assistance has indeed helped Nepal, or if it has made the country weaker.
A development cooperation report published by the Ministry of Finance says Nepal received US$1.4 billion in foreign aid last fiscal year. Of this, 42% was in grants and the rest were loans and technical assistance. A little less than one-third was spent ‘out of the budget’ or disbursed directly by the donors or development partners, and a chunk of this was allocated for ‘capacity building’.
The world continues to invest in us. Every year the amount increase, with the justification that Nepal lacks ‘capacity’. The reality, however, is that a large number of perfectly ‘capable’ Nepalis are underemployed or unemployed, and many of them are working abroad due to lack of opportunities in their own country.
At a recent dinner, I asked the head of a major development agency in Kathmandu if she knew how much capacity they had built in Nepal, and the simple answer was “no”. In one village, where a lot of aid goes into empowering rural, vulnerable, untouchable, poor women, the justification for why a participant was attending a particular training was because she already had certificates for all other issues.
A few years ago, a small group of us were having dinner in Dhangadi and talking about corruption. The restaurant owner overheard us and contributed the following: “We recently had a trainer who came and made a bill for 50 people being trained for 3 days without holding the training.”
I am sure we all have these stories to share. To use an analogy, there is an energy drink in the market, which is as old as foreign aid, and each year the advertisements say it contains ‘even more vitamins’ than before.
Today one out of four Nepalis are living abroad. Many of them are recognised for their capacity to do just about anything. The ones who stay back are often labelled ‘incapable’. At a recent ‘capacity building’ event for a large group of senior government officers who were serving in remote areas of Nepal, a participant was overheard saying: “If the trainer was capable, he would have left Nepal a long time back.”

