Kiran May 4, 2010
great piece...
would be better if this was in nepali and printed on a national broadsheet.
kiran
Bobby May 4, 2010
I have been wondering how come every news in the daily newspaper was highlighting "peaceful banda" from the day first. There was news that maoists have forcefully closed exam center, tearing the exam papers and vandalising the exam center. Yet journalist are chanting " very peaceful strike". People are walking to airport for hours and hours. Schools have been closed. Even Government organizations are forced to close. Farmers are trashing rotten vegetables. Sick are getting sicker, poor are becoming poorer and maoist still announcing this strike is for the people.
I still can not understand why do all newspapers are still giving priority to the maoist activities more than anything in Nepal. Is the media scared to write about the truth. There is no doubt that maoist won the election and also was in the chief of the power to run the country. But they quit on their own. They could have done necessary action when they were in the powerful position. At present, they are going back to the street and it is funny. Because, they have majority of sabhasads and should have work with the other political parties with cooperation and coordination. Instead, they quit and yet trying to do protest just to make those young maoist active for sometime. What happens when the strike ends. What would those young maoist do again? Are they just meant to be on the street? Are they not entitled to have education and the employment?
Kunda Sir, thank you for sharing what you witness!
Tashi Tamang May 4, 2010
In the name of PEACE they beg, In the name of PEACE they take the name of Buddha, In the name of PEACE they protest and in the name of PEACE they called Nepal bandha, and they proudly say bandha went of PEACEFULLY, I laugh at these stupid netas. In the reality each bandha cost millions and billions of losses, losses of life is there too, losses of urgent treatment, losses of education. All these stupid ideas of bandha continued for many years but logical ideas of real peace and progress is not carried out in by any of these political leaders.
OUT OF NARROW MINDED LEADERS, CAME OUT STUPID FOOLISH SUPPORTERS! OUT OF NEPAL BANDHA, CAUSED MANY SUFFERING AND LOSSES FOR NEPAL!
NEPAL ONLY IS THE COUNTRY IN THIS WORLD TO HURT ONESELF BY KEEPING THE PRACTICE OF NEPAL CLOSURE!
BANDHA: MEANING CLOSE, CLOSE EVERYTHING FOR THE SAKE OF SUCCESSFUL CLOSURE STRIKE! IT NOW SEEMS THAT THE MENTALITY OF OPENNESS IN THE MINDS OF NEPALESE SEEMS TO HAVE BEEN CLOSED AFTER ALL THESE STUPID CULTURE OF NEPAL CLOSING!
Sorry to say this: but if I have powers in my hand, in the real name of PEACE and HARMONY in Nepal, I should first shoot down all these stupid political leaders of Nepal, only then Nepal will find peace and harmony! It seems that they are looking for that day to come!
DOWN WITH STUPID IDEOLOGY OF MAOISM IN NEPAL!
Kundale May 4, 2010
Well Mr. Dixit... here's something to chew on for all your complaining... was Janandolan II that threw out Gyanendra and restored Loktantra any different? If so, how so..... if not, why are you complaining?
Ram Karna May 4, 2010
Nepal wanted Lok tantra isn't it. This is what you get. Nepalis do not know how to rule themselves.
jange May 4, 2010
Kunda ji. According to the NT, the Maoists are the only party representing change. Have you forgotten that so easily?
Dimag chhaina? May 4, 2010
Kundale,
Akhir ma jasto sukai Janandolan bhaye pani Rs. 6000 pareko khasi lai Rs. 2000 diyera taap kasna ta paidaina ni -- tyo pani euta sadharan sau sita.
Rajesh May 4, 2010
Well... we all have a lot of time to chew ... on what? That we voluntarily participated in Janandolan II to see Nepal in this state ?? Of course, people should have the right to choose whether to participate or not, in any protest called upon by any political party. If people were given the option, how successful would this band be ? Maybe, there lies the difference ... between Janandolan II and the current band. But in a country where the basic fundamental right of every human being, the right to live, is violated everyday, of course we should not expect the right to freedom. If every person were given freedom to choose, I am sure this band would be over in no time.
XYZ May 4, 2010
@kundale
First of all, I do not remember any robbery in the valley .
Secondly, we did not have any of these god-damned YCL operatives threatening lives of people. Nor was there any hypocrisy on bandh elevation, like one in front of my eyes yesterday (May 3, 2010): 6 - 8 PM was supposed to be a time of elevation... and what do the protesters do? They trash two motorcycles, and beat the riders brutally.
I wonder when this country will get out of maoist-terrorism. These people deserved to be guillotined like Louie and her Queen.
ahh... what need I speak against... the failed ideology known as "communism" ? sheesh... and please don't cite China as an example.. anyone conscious knows better of China than "they have a communist government".
rajan May 4, 2010
Its very ironic that while the entire country is suffering, what do our so called, people elected officials doing ? Going to radission on the pretext of finding a solution, eating a very delicious meal and deciding to continue the discussion the next day. Shame on those people. But then what about the people? When will the people stand up for themselves? When wil they stop following any party and lead themselves? If the maoists leader were genuine on their intentions, how come they are not sheltering any of the people who they brought from out of the valley? Why make the city dwellers suffer ? Why are the leaders eating in radission when their followers are falling sick of diahorrea? I am not criticising the maoists only. The other parties would have done the same. Shame on you so called leaders. You truly dont have any intention for the country. Its just for your own pockets. Someday the people will rise and when they do, there will be no prachanda leading them or girija leading them, their will be just the common people who are fighting for their right to live, and live peacefully !!!! I really hope the people can rise and see above these petty bickerings between the parties. May our country live and may the common people live. Death to the leaders !!!!
smt May 4, 2010
The utterly selfish parties are making the Nepalese pay for the blunder they committed by trying to bring the maoist to the mainstream politics. Just look at what these terrorist maoist have done. They tried destroying all the crucial institution of the nation including religion, monarchy , structure of the country. And the funny thing is that these other parties like UML and congress do not realise that they are on the verge of being wiped.
Today is the third day of the bandh, and they are still fighting for power with the least concern for the people. People have become like prisoners and all the nepalese nationwide have become subject to human rights abuse. The Human rights group are nowhere to be found. So are the nagarik samaj !Where are these guys now? They are not issueing statement in favor the people.
It becomes clear that unless the denizens of Kathmandu come down on the street and take the final decision nothing is going to happen. The maoist will continue to call strikes, the parties will continue to plunder the nation and take decisions at their will, wont stop running the country at India's beck and call !!
Upon failing to write the constitution, all the existing politicians should be black-listed and barred from entering politics in Nepal. Nepalese citizens should come down and on the street to finish this job of cleansing the dirt that is in Nepal's assembly and in the street.
May May 4, 2010
Kundaji should do an update: today the Lord of the Flies aren't even allowing bicycles and forcibly flattening the tires of any bicycle that dares pass the barricades. They have vandalized numerous vegetable and milk sidewalk shops as apart of their "peaceful" bandh. In western Nepal they beat up day laborers mining sand. This Janandolan 3 is all about getting to power by punishing and traumatizing the people. May they rot in hell.
mahesh May 4, 2010
As has been mentioned that its not a peaceful banda at all. And all these netas are not working for Democracy. the fundamental of which is freedom of choice and freedom of expression. People are scared to use these basic fundamentals of democracy. What is wrong if I chose to ride my bike during banda or support King that is my freedom of choice. If these politicians are scared that I will use my choice then they are no better than the Totalrians, we had in past. And as I see these politicians cant support these basics then what democracy are they fighting for and what progress in the democratic front can we expect from these ......(whatever word u might want to use).
Malaya Shahi May 4, 2010
Mr. Dixit,
It is nice chronicle to read through. But please remember that it was Himal media that gave so much space to Maoist ideology in its publications (in the name of inclusion or for commercial benefit?) that half of your readers must have thought you have Maoist inclination at some point. You should take the responsibility to unnecessarily spreading the Maoist thoughts and I am sure history will certainly decide that.
But it is amazing that you took a u-turn in your approach as your printing press was vandalised by Maoist cadres and you chose to write more against them. You are not reporting as a journalist with an independent view but more through your personal vengence and encounters with Maoist.
How do you expect readers to think that you are doing a credible blogging?
Bikash May 4, 2010
Well written and thank you for filling us with what exactly is happening in the street...
Few months ago a friend of mine forwarded me an email; he didn't send that email in context of Nepal however it somewhat make sense.
When Nazis started to spread around in German, majority of Germans didn't support yet they kept quiet because their perceptions was it is not effecting my livelihood. By the time Nazi started effecting general populations' livelihood it was too late to do anything....
When Stalin rose in Russia, majority of population didn't support Stalin, yet again majority of Russians' persception was, its not effecting my livelihoods, in no time Stalin killed millions of people and yet history has told us that those millions lost their lives not for good...
Majority of Nepalese population do not support Maoist, proof is number of votes secured by maoist among total vote casted during constitutional assembly's election.... yet Maoist are trying to bring on their own changes and force upon their way of rules at any cost and majority of Nepalese population are still doing nothing because of the perception among us is, "it's not effecting my livelihood..." I still have food on my table, my kids are secure... few days Bandhas only has short term effect... lets think again... during 2036 janamat sangraha... more than 50% of population chose panchayat... yet in 2046 andolan not all nepalese people had a choice to make their own choice yet majority of nepalese accepted the changes which was forced upon them and try to get along with their lives... in the similar fashion so called lok tantra has been forced upon us... we are still trying to get along with our lives because it hasn't effected our livelihoods..... I don't know how many tantra's will be forced upon us down the track.....
LETS THINK SHOULD WE JUST BECOME A SPECTATOR AND LET THIS SMALL PROBLEM SPREAD AROUND AND EFFECT OUR, OUR FUTURE GENERATION'S LIVELIHOOD
christina dorman May 4, 2010
hi kunda,
just tell me mouch does the government pay you to narrate as if you are a government spokesperson. your views are clearly jaundiced. while event he government tv puts is both sides, your reporting has always been against the maoists. shame on your unprofessional work!
it would be more believable if you reported neutrally rather than exagerating against the maoists. don't you see any thing wrong from the government side? answer it for yourself man
nepali May 4, 2010
now we nepalese have to come to streets to stop this terror of maoist. otherwise, our nepal will be no better communist country.
Baneshwor May 4, 2010
What has the post-90's exercise in "freedom" taught us?
a) The lame excuse for leaders are free to take bribes with shameless impunity, flush down all sense of decency and shame down the toilet, and bring a general sense of directionlessness and hopelessness in the country. Yet, they are free to strut around in press conferences and in public vehicles with lights, sirens and all the accompanying paraphernalia without the slightest bit of guilt or shame at the fiasco and the culture of corruption they have created in the country. The NETAS, in their delusion or their incorrigibly stupid and unrepentant cognitive and moral being (I still haven't figured out which) are still free to act like we owe them a great deal for having liberated us from god knows what.
b) The party workers are free to vandalize property, enforce shutdowns and bring chaos in the lives of ordinary people.
c)The analysts, experts, NGOs and INGOs foreign and domestic are free to mint dollars giving their expert opinion on a plethora of issues with sophisticated sounding names like: "conflict resolution", "poverty alleviation" and the like. They are free to perpetuate the environment of desperation and want to secure their jobs till god knows when.
d) The ordinary people are free to wonder what on earth is going around them!
MASK May 4, 2010
@XYZ or those who ever are bitching about communism
Failed Ideology.. Communism?? Opposite of communism is Capitalism. Communism is required in NEPAL , Where there is a limit to ownership of property by an individual. Please get that in your head.
You cannot compare communsim and democracy, a country can be democratic and communist or a communist republic. You can probably compare democratic and republic. Please get this in your head as well.
Other thing : MADHAV KUMAR NEPAL needs to be out of power, first of all he doesnt deserve to be a prime minister. He is god damned species of usless human being, Neither can he lead nor is he strong enough to do anything good in this country.
Shyam Giri May 4, 2010
The people are tired and sick of bandhs in Nepal. They are so common that people have a joke saying that there is a call for bandh even if some one's wife elopes. That has been a part of Nepal political culture which is a omen for the development of Nepal. The recent bandh does not have any meaning since the Maoist themself have a good number of constituion assembly members and if they want to impeach the Prime Minister they should get the majority of CA members and pass of vote of non confidence and dislodge him from the position. It is not necessary to call bandhs for days and disrupt the lives and businesses of the ordinary people. Who is going to compensate for the losses in income for the millions of people in the city. It is very pathetic and deplorable for the parites to act in this manner. It shows how greedy the parties are in wanting to usurp power by force. No one is concerned about the security, water and electricity supply in the city. The denizens of Kathmandu now should form their own groups to ban these bandhs and extortions.
Kal May 4, 2010
We have been so accustomed to violence that we have our definition of violence. For us there is no violence if there is no bloodshed. Living in an environment of fear and harassment, coercion has become a routine. We live as if we are happy. When there is a BANDH day we are happy that we have got another day off. When the media says that protests are peaceful we take it for granted.
But why ??? why should we always live in terror? Why cant we say no to terror??? No party can claim today that it carries out peaceful means to achieve its goals. Every party has its own goondas who are spreading terror amongst as the PEOPLE. Is is really a time to say no to TERROR? Cant we general people unite once again for our rights? Is it realy justifiable that 100000 people can take hostage 3000000 people?
shree 5 May 4, 2010
Reading all these articles I came to the conclusion that real educated rastra vakta nepali dont want NEPAL BANDHA at all.
we can change our society just by educating and teaching them patriotism.
if we just educate them they become YE MALEE.
If we just teach them patriotism they become MAUBADIISS.
As H2 and O2 but are flammable but yelds H2O in conbination similarly we can get good nepali guy by educating and teaching patriotism to country.
No guns but bullets to Maubadissss
John May 4, 2010
Kund,
Thank you for sharing the painful experiences of Nepali people. I think this is the extreme behavior of the Maoists and they are desperetly running for power. They have not respect to the Nepali people. They only know how to exploit the poor and marginalized people.
I know all the people who came to Kathamndu for demonstration is because of fear. If they do not follow the Maoists order then they will be panalised. So general people can not protest the Maoists because they have the guns and they can still kill the people if their order is not followed.
I have only one request, when you write such a great article please avoid some of the Nepali words such as "kangresis, kiran pasal etc. if you expect international community to read. If you are targeting to the Nepalease people (off course you should) then please write totally in Nepali lanuage.
Appreciated for your continuous efforts and contribution for the democracy of Nepal.
John, Denmark
ripvanwinkle May 4, 2010
at this rate anexxing nepal with india seems a good idea. i just want to get on with my life,
krishna gurung May 4, 2010
if maoist are doing it for nepal then why all nepalese are suffering? why are they calling nepal bandhha as it was used be a only ladder for power for parties ...why cant they wait ...why dont they believe that peoples power is powerful then bullet.
dont underestimate nepalese poor people one day they will unite against nepal bandhha because one days bandhha is equivalent to millions rupees and we cant offord this.
please lets not be biased to any party lets be a nepali. thanks.
and thank you mr dixit for your effort
Raj May 4, 2010
First of all I am against a Band whether it is a peaceful or with voience. It efffects common people's life, in our country still so many people under the poverty line and have to earn each day so that they can earn their living.
Especially at the present situation the way all the political parties are behaving is really bad manner. When will they lift themselves above their personal benefit and think of this whole nation, which is one of the poorest nation in the world, still so many poeple are living under the line of poverty.
Our economy is in worst condition, we still need aid from ohter nation to run our country, if people working in middleeast or in other country doing labout jobs or those low paid jobs just because their is no jobs inour country, donot send remittence the economy will be even worse.
Well what I want from all the political party is try to build the nation, leave the selfishness.
ajay May 4, 2010
I hate to say this but Mr. Kundan you are very critical towards anykind of rule. First you heavily criticized the monarchy rule, here you are critical about the past congressi rule , uml rule and now maobadi's movement. If influential people like you are only going to spend your intelligence and time in criticizing about things then there's no much hope for nepal now, is there? Instead of reminding and highlighting the facts we are too well aware about why dont you jsut take a retirement. The problem is not that we are not informed but infact the opposite. Sansani news and side ma basera judging others actions thats all you are good at. Charity garnus hajur tara journalism chod-dinu paryo, another option would be to open a political party, adopt the philosophy of Obama( the president of the US )path towards giving hopes to the Nepalese people , work hard to garner as much support you can from the nepalese people and lead us through. i will support you 100% i promise you.
zook May 5, 2010
Mr. Dixit, Media is such a powerful tool. Yet you haven't been able to use it in a proper way. I remember how proudly all of the media were supporting these politicians back during Jana Andolan II. Now look at the state of this country. Instead of lobbying for or against a political party, why don't you inform and educate people. These Maoists are taking advantage of poor and uneducated people in rural Nepal. They are using them. We all know that.The only way to stop this is to educate the people. No one can reach them better than the media. YOUR MEDIA HAS SUCH A POTENTIAL. ACT BEFORE IT'S TOO LATE..... (P.S. When you know that maoists are forcibly asking for donations from everyone, why don't i see it in the papers, or see it on tv? Why is the media quiet on this one?
Amused May 5, 2010
Kunda, we had thought your degeneration was not as complete as your younger brother's, that you at least cared to pretend. Sad to see you exposed in this manner. Dismissing tens of lakhs of ragged villagers as Maoist thugs? So much for your "democratic" credentials!
suresh May 5, 2010
From Nepalies who want to work for the country ,had not even ever thought of being out of country for further studies,work or something else , who want to utilize the brain for the development of the country, who always is worried for the financial, status & development of the country BANDH is
"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""POTATO"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""
Natanekafi May 5, 2010
I'd like to post a poem by Langston Hughes here, for all those netas who promise to instil fearlessness and work towards development of the country. (Obviously, they're faking it)
If only they understood;
Freedom
Is just frosting,
On somebody else's
Cake-
Till we
learn how to
Bake.
Bikalpa May 5, 2010
Well this is happened due to the lack of leadership in our country.There is no such leader which is mandatory for all so we can do one thing all party must undergo on the leadership of king so that king should utilised best experience to correct toilet thrown leader of modern age.
Otherwise country should be given to the lease for european union or Japan by bidding for the coming 20 years so that all the bloody fool leaders eradication for the betterment of people for not poisionous leaders benefit.
Please ready for this type of mentality so that we can approach with europian union or other.
John M. Kelleher May 5, 2010
"Lord of the Flies kids armed with sharpened bamboo staves" - a spot-on description, which I think captures perfectly both the immaturity [physical as well as mental/moral] of these junior Maobadis and also the fanatical, mean-spirited stupidity which has overtaken their thinking.
It's just a pity the Nepali Times was such an enthusiastic cheerleader for Nepal's new ganatantric order and a "nuanced approach" to bring the Maoists into the mainstream. We're seeing the dividends of that "nuanced approach" right now.
Kunda Dixit is almost certainly correct to observe that people are afraid to talk to the press about all this. Yet that does not absolve the foreign press, UN staffers, and INGO's of any blame for failing to notice the extortion and threats which have inetivably accompanied the "Tesro Jana Andolan." Foreign press staff and international agencies could, with just a modicum of curiosity and effort, find out what is going on in the streets. Instead, we all have to swallow our disgust as we read the OHCHR's latest report praising the Maobadis for an exemplary peaceful demonstration.
bottomline May 5, 2010
the misguided, short-sighted, ignorant, inhumane, unethical, irresponsible, unaccountable, and blatantly arrogant course of actions and behaviors of the maobadi leadership is possible only because we the people bend over and take it. yes fear and terrorism is the currency with which they impose their will on the masses of people, but for how long? when there is a 'circle the capital' ring of maobadis around the ringroad, why is there not a triple or even quadruple circle of everyday people to show our disgust? terror. fear. simple as that. yes wew the nepalis. the gorkhalis. bending over now and receiving. terrorized. maybe we will have a Haiti or Chile level earthquake here soon that will flatten everything. sometimes a massive calamity is the only thing that will bring people together. and yes it will force us to unite as a country. but for now, on we go, as we have for years now, maobadi terrorists having their fun at the expense of everyday hardworking people trying to raise their families in peace. shame on you maobadis, you blind and ignorant fools, you dont even know what you are doing.
Tilak Gurung May 5, 2010
Kunda is innate provoker and manipulator expert potentially danger than maoist for common peoaple of Nepal who's media and intilectual potentiality was always used to back in service of Post regimen i.e. an absolute monarqui of Nepal before People Revolution II/2005. Do think people forget you so quickly because you're powerful man with higher intelectual coefficient or Do you think nepalese and other people all over the worlds keen to know what's really happaning in Nepal are alls fools. Use your humand potentiality and proffesionality for common people of nepal. Not always for money, power higher classe like you.
Tilak May 5, 2010
Kunda Dai you must be doing something right if all the Rajabadis think you are Maobadi, and all the Maobadis think you are Rajabadi! Congratulations! Keep up the great work you are doing at Nepali Times!
buddhi May 5, 2010
Thanks Kunda jee for publishing nice over views of so called "peaceful bandha". You know the famous Nepali proverb, "Ejjat hune ko po beijeet hunchha, ejjat nai nahune ko ke ko beijet" all leaders have such cagatory. They don't know about their duties and responsibilities. Only lured for power. When they will get right way and their responsibilities? It is not so good to say, the massive earthquake will destroy all so called netas and will fruitfull for people.
Pemba May 5, 2010
I loved your blog and the reference to Lord of the Flies. I just
hope we are lucky enough to have a Piggy and a Ralph show us the road
to reason and decency soon. Do you remember the last bit of the story ?
the very end of it where it seems that even Golding kind of gave in to the
irony that maybe the only lifeline to democracy had to go through the
uniformed soldier ?....hmmm....something to think about...
Bhatti May 5, 2010
Ahhh....you high class elites, foreign diplomats, European and American expatriates, all you see is vulgarity, stupidity, suppressed masses, forced villagers and out-of-valley-ians joining a "stupid propaganda machine."
These folks are not being chained, and if you think they are being forced to participate in the protest, that is where you miss the point. People want change and you Kathmanduians don't want to give it to us. The elites, the politicians who have got stale and by now rotten with their long comfortable stay in Kathmandu, don't understand Nepal at all.
Mr. Kunda Ji, taking a short excursion through Nepal once in awhile in your east-west trip does not give you the entitlement to understand the reality of situations in countryside. Yes, you are liberal, you are intellectual, a fine writer, and well-connected I should say, and born with silver spoon, but one has to be born, live and have toiled in countryside before you and your lot can see the other side of the protest.
Hope this protest goes smoothly without any violence, and hope the Maoists party is allowed to govern the country for its designated period of time without interference with India and China. Come on, country has been a given a great leap of faith, and yes, am worried about junior cadres who running high on hormones and excitement, but one has to take the whole journey, the bigger picture. Himal Media and the rest of the media, I don't know where you stand or whose side you are on, but times like this is an opportunity for you folks to decide where you want your media house to be, and where you want your country to be, hopefully you will be on a side of reality and truth, ironically, and regrettably, I do appreciate and enjoy your contributions and publications.
not that I am a Maoist but I sympathize more with Prachanda and Baburam and the co. than other political leaders.
Norbu May 5, 2010
Kunda Ji,
In reality, majority of Nepalese are poor but are sojo and saadha sidha Nepali, they are truly simple living people living their life contentedly and peacefully. Unfortunately, due to the political revival in Nepal by the narrow minded politicians, things have changed from good to bad and now bad to worse. During Licchavi period Nepal once was like heaven on earth, a truly religious and kind hearted king with his subjects living peacefully and harmoniously!
In this blog some people talk of Maoist bringing change in the country, but they never thought of how the changes comes? Talking of transforming whole nation is easy, but in reality without transforming oneself, how come Maoist going to bring change? If they stop! using violence, extortion, false promises and oppression, then they can bring change in Nepal? We need to transform ourselves to bring change in Nepal!
All these innocent farmers and workers are day dreaming with the false promises heard from Maoist propaganda, it is truly very pitiable that many people are fooled in such a way! For that day dream to come true, many innocents sacrificed with their lives! With the turn of law, with it's causes and causalities, all the narrow mided politicians including Prachanda, Baburam, and all the narrow minded politburo members will suffer the consequences in very near future. I am optimistic that Maoism in Nepal will fail totally, that is for sure!
Kunda ji, thank you very much for this good article. Please keep up your good work to bring awareness on narrow minded and crooked politicians in Nepal.
SAVE NEPAL!
XYZ May 5, 2010
@MASK
[QUOTE]Failed Ideology.. Communism?? Opposite of communism is Capitalism. Communism is required in NEPAL , Where there is a limit to ownership of property by an individual. Please get that in your head. [/QUOTE]
I don't want to start a flame war here..
Please go read the Communist Manifesto to get a better view on Communism. To correct you, what you have talked about I support, limit to ownership... that is a principle of SOCIALISM dude...
Communism points towards absolute abolition of private property, and it is easy to see why it gets impractical: you just need to have a critical eye, and blabbering emotionally.
Perhaps a little bit of reading and thinking... here's some food for the mind.. from "Nature's Eternal Religion" by Ben Klassen:
"Communism designates those productive and creative forces of our society to which we owe in such large part the benefits of a productive civilization, as "bourgeois." It then lashes out with unparalleled fury at the bourgeois and tells us over and over again that they must be destroyed. Instead of giving credit where credit is due, it slanders and vilifies these constructive and productive elements, namely the bourgeois or the capitalists, as the ultimate in evil."
"While the communist slave laborer is toiling away twelve hours a day and then comes home to a dingy, dirty, filthy, crowded little apartment shared with other families, his bosses have opulent palaces spread all over the countryside. They drive the best of cars, chauffeur driven, of course, and eat the best of foods. Not only that, but they have the best of planes at their disposal to fly wherever they see fit to govern their slave laborers. These communist bosses usually also have at their disposal imported clothes and tailors and a galaxy of servants. "
We can see Mr. Dahal's et al's status right now, can't we?
I have heard (literally) that all local co-ordinators of the bandh are accumulating about Rs. 10 lakh each. They were talking about how this has "become a new business" for them.
Sorry for not being able to give an extended argument at the moment, thanks to my exam preparations, but if anyone thinks about communism peacefully, you can see loopholes and impracticalities everywhere...
Sujan Shakya May 5, 2010
Great piece. Don't go for Maoist army's well managed rebuttals. They are known to be very active.
@ Kundale: The difference between this time's protest and jana andolan 2 is all very obvious unless you have a closed mind: it was by people, from all walks of life; this is by a party, particularly its power-hungry megalomaniac chairman desperate for PM's chair. This time the ordinary people -- who do not subscribe to any political ideology -- are not taking part in the selfish protest. Got that?
@Bhatti: You have all the freedom to believe that these villagers came to the capital on their own. The real reasons are here: from the promised Rs 1400 per person to getting a free ride to see Kathmandu to being forced to come. That's true for most who came here.
XYZ May 5, 2010
^^
Rather than blabbering emotionally, I meant..
bass May 5, 2010
Jana Andola II,
How come JANA, when the only JANA'S are the ones who are supporting them . ( by will or by force, others doesn't count ).
For the people who are not supporting them.....whom do u trust, if not them?? Then whom? Where is the educated force? where are u people??? Fancing your hot bath???? hehehe shame on you too like the netas out here.Force (majority), don't u see it's only it that works out here. We want the change, but not for the interest of an individual or A group... there is an urgency of the educated force!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
U guys who are abroad, are atleast lucky to hear from us now. Who knows in the future? Next Cuba or China???? Hardy !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! but in making!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Save Nepal May 5, 2010
Good article......
Can't believe once I was so proud of being a Nepali and now when people ask me where I am from, I say I am from Asia..... I want to believe in my country and feel the same proudness which I had couple of decades back........
Are we done yet? May 5, 2010
Yawn!! All this political vacillation is getting tiresome as one pathetic, avaricious old codger replaces another in this endless gallery of rogues, be it Maoist, Congress, Muppet or Jackass. Twenty plus years of strife and displacement and it’s still the same old merry-go-round. Another generation lost, yet another opportunity squandered and it seems that no one is really counting the cost. In the meantime, petty-proles-turned-terrorists brazenly hold sway over the capital where a population cowers in terror. Not exactly ‘progress’ by any measure.
What gives? Where is that gravitas that causes a people to say ‘enough’? I thought that the Nepali people had it in spades but apparently not. To begin with, where is the response to this indignation – the counter-activism borne out of the swagger so characteristic of Kathmandu? Where are the fearless Rambos and assorted he-men that usually lounge about busy shopping arcades, the wannabe mafiosi that frequent the nightclubs, the ersatz Bollywood hipsters on their pesty little Indian bikes that are usually such a menace? Shouldn't the collective machismo of Kathmandu’s essay some sort of a response to this impertinent curtailing of their freedoms or I daresay civil rights?
Then again they’re probably too busy catching up on the latest Bollywood shenanigans or else sorting out their wardrobe for when this bandh thing is finally over. Really, on a an international scale of terrorism, this lot of Maoists terrorists are a laughable bunch – a rag tag horde of feebly armed peasants strutting about in knock-off camouflage that would make an Al-Qaeda fashion guru weep, leave alone Isaac Mizrahi.. Hell, there are malnutritioned terrorists in Somalia that are more convincing or have you not seen those emaciated, rail-thin Somail pirates endlessly paraded on CNN?
So let’s get that testosterone level up, drop the hair gel or grooming product, turn off that inane Bollywood rubbish and take a step towards freedom. Get mobilized and get heard. Get out there and (to paraphrase an erstwhile US leader) ‘kick some ass’. Let’s get these moonlighting terrorists out of the capital and back onto the farms doing an honest day’s work. Then let’s get the rascals out of office and sort this country out before another generation loses out on their rights to the pursuit of freedom and happiness. Easier said than done? Maybe, but you’ve got to start somewhere. Ah yes, and if you’re unsure as to the hows of ‘kicking ass’ might I suggest that the collected works of Hollywood supremo Steven Segal might prove very instructive. And he’s a Rinpoche to boot!!! So you can't go wrong.
arjun May 5, 2010
be a politician or be a civilized person!!!
i used to read your artical but i never saw like this egoist artical. you remember the jana andolan 2, those was violence but still we say its peace. we kicked off the king but we didn't kicked off our dirty and corrupted pilitican, if u still belive in change of country you have to think and write about the change of this. we all nepali people should know, like our pour country whose politics runs by india and its dominated. its not so easy to come out from. our base should be strong, we need to change our politican and trend of politics. if you see any other independent country's history they already suffer like this kind of phase. they already struggle and sacrity their generations. so we have to believe if we want to change face of nepal we have to be ready for struggle to make new developed country. moast shoul keep continue untill other political parties feels that they have to be change not like giving MRP contract to india as like their property and sujata says nepal has to be sorry to india.
im nepali i love nepal as like all so,
WE HAVE ALREADY FINISHED HALFWAY BY KICK OF KING, WE HAVE TO CONTINUE UNTIL CONPLETE
pramod May 5, 2010
i am surprised that moist say its peaceful banda. They are not doing any peaceful thing other than torching people. They are making stay their people in schools, lodge and so on but now they are making them stay in even students private hostels.......disgusting
charlie May 5, 2010
I read few of comments which are given above. I can not believe Nepalese people. So stupid, All political leaders are fighting each other, M Nepal is sitting in chair who is already lost regular election, corruption all over the place, army is killing and rapping local public. Food and fuel price are high, private schools are extremely expensive. But most of the comments are blamming maoist. Who brought all these things, Maoist ? . Maoist just got last year. Maoist running for equal rights for everybody. Do you think how poor in Nepal and how is life of poor people. All these situation brought past government. UML, Congress, and RPP are responsible for that.
SRB May 5, 2010
Check out the lyrics of "War Pigs" by Ozzy Osbourne... exactly what is happening. The first part, at least...
@bass
[quote] For the people who are not supporting them…..whom do u trust, if not them?? Then whom? Where is the educated force? where are u people??? Fancing your hot bath???? hehehe shame on you too like the netas out here. [/quote]
Consider this simplified game theoretical situation (which is a very close adaptation of the game "Prisoner's Dilemma"):
Individual Others:
| Protest No Protest
Protest -> +2.5/+2.5 -10/0
No Protest -> +5/+2.95 -3/-3
Explanation of Payoffs:
If an individual (or a small group) protests the bandh, but others don't, the small group is up a lot of trouble. So the payoff is -10 for Individuals, and the protest will not likely succeed, so the payoff for 'others' (the entire community, let's say) will be 0.
Likewise, if nobody protests, all will have to face the bandh crises so -3 for both.
If an individual doesn't protest, he will be comparatively 'safer' than others who go and protest, speaking probabilistically... so +5 for individual and +2.95 for others.
If all protest, the bandh will be over and everyone gets a +2.5
Note that I am not taking into account other factors (for example, the probabilistic corrections of forces of human rights, international pressure, likelihood of the protest turning extremely violent etc) , as the game would get excessively complicated (and this game is still a good approximation to explain my point).
Now what the individual or others will do is, they will try to maximize their own payoff. If the individual protests, he is at a loss at both levels: whether others protest or they don't. If others protest, he gets a +2.5 (compared to a +5), and if others don't, he gets a -10 (instead of a -3). Similar is the case for others. So the most likely situation is that nobody protests, which brings a payoff of -3/-3 and this is the Nash's Equilibrium for the game.
Note that it would be erroneous to compare diagonally in this game, and look at the potential win-win situation unless an agreement is forged, one that compels both "individual" and "others" to protest.
CyberLekali May 5, 2010
The famous poem can be applied in Nepal:
When the Maoists came for the Industrialists,
I remained silent;
I was not an Industrialist.
When they locked up the Democrats,
I remained silent;
I was not a Democrat.
When they came for the trade teachers,
I did not speak out;
I was not a teacher.
When they came for the Hindus,
I remained silent;
I wasn't a Hindu.
When they came for the journalists,
I did not speak out;
I was not a journalist.
When they came for me,
there was no one left to speak out.
PRadyumna May 5, 2010
MR Kunda,
There are few truths I believe and if you could not agree any of them, it will be a surprise.
1. People wanted change after 2nd janaandolan.
2.People ( as seen) voted maoists as a largest party, with the hope of change come true..
3. Madhav Nepal has been rejected as a good leader by majority of people, they never want Mr. Nepal to be a PM.
4. Madhav Nepal does not deserve to be PM and his being PM is against the people's wish of change.
5.Madhav Nepal knows very well, this is the ending of his time in politics, after he resign, he will be lost from whole political scene.
6. Madhav Nepal never wants to resign from post.
7. People's verdict goes against Madhav Nepal and if people stay silent, why would Ma Ne Resign?
8.So, people said, Madhav Nepal,you are not our choice..but no one would hear that.
9. That is pity in Nepal, untill and unless there is a bang, no one would give attention to it.
10. So after a year, if maoists are trying to create that bang and take out Madhav Nepal, that is fine. Why do we support Madhav Nepal who cant bring change, who has lost election ?
11. If you have any solid ideas on how to take MAdhav Nepal out and restore the multi party government matching with people's verdict, tell it to media, tell it to people. Else, if silence and peaceful protest causes madhav nepal to ignore it and continue his game, what is another alternative to halting everything, creating a bang, and alerting or throwing away madhav nepal ?
Just MAoists are doing a mistake, they understand all things, but they are creating bang in peoples workplace, houses and business. Actually they should create bang in madhav nepal's PM quarter and halt his business and if needed, living and life. LEt the foods not enter his quarter, let the cars and people not enter or exit his quarter a. I really doubt if Maoists have got that guts as well.. No one stands for people, they are standing against people and not against the villians like madhav nepal or Bhim Rawals.
deshbaktha May 5, 2010
kundhan je u are great..hamro deshko ahile ko abasekta tapai haru jastai patrakar haruko cha milkomilk waterkowater...thanks
MASK May 5, 2010
@XYZ...
the failed ideology known as “communism” ?? Was what i was pointing out, you have choice to pick what you want to believe, emotionally or not :-).
"what you have talked about I support, limit to ownership… that is a principle of SOCIALISM dude… " - Mate, whats the principle of Communism?? Totalitarianism. Well, i am no expert, but who needs to reads you know. I SAY YOU CAN RUN A VEICHLE WITH PETROL, XYZ SAYS NO, YOU CAN RUN A VECHILE WITH DIESEL. Principle is the same mate limit to ownership, Though Socialsm allows some amount of captialism if you get your facts right this time.
My whole point is that you cannot claim ideology to be a failed one just because somone cannot implement it. Giving you a very good example as you are a student, i suppose you are a good one.:-), you cannot blame the book if you cannot clear your exam can you ?? Its just that you have not read it well.
I feel you just hate the word communism, without knowing what it is, It like trying to preach hindusm when you have not read a word of GITA.
If communism is a failed ideology than every damn ideology is a failed ideology becuase nothing seems to work in NEPAL. Now does it ?
I dont want to prolong further, Best of luck for your exams, read well. When you read, don't just consider what the author thinks, consider what you think. - Dead poets society.
ankit sharma May 5, 2010
If you sow poison, poison will grow!!!Nepalese people deserve this because they supported illigal weapons with mass (so called movement of 2063) and ballet ( by voting maoist...And from that time all journalist are exposed of doing yellow journalism because a difianc to the state was done by journalists, civil servants and others.....A change based in anarchy has brought anarchy.............Nothing new for me to hear or read::::::::I was expecting this since then!!!!!Truely speaking, if same political structure is going to be continued with same leaders, so called civil society and journalist.....The day Nepal will die....I will not cry because from last 3 years I knew that it is going to die...so my sorrow for the death of nation will just see the day and say "i am with you for this day since Baisakh 11, 2063 to see this day"
pravasi nepali May 5, 2010
All now; nepal needs is a big natural calamity like chile,haiti; everything will faltten down. Then only the gauless will go back to their villages. Why don't they understand that farmers as well as engg. play imp role in national economy. The economy is on brink of collapse; what do these people think. They will continue dancing drunk on the streets of capital; not doing work themselves and not letting others work too; how will the essentials from in and outside country come. Chinese and indians wont come with masu bhat in plate to feed you.So, live and let live. They are just being used as pawns by prachande, baburame, hisila kichkandi,etc. Once they get power; all will be forgotten.
And how can maoists be so stupid. Their leaders' children study and work in west;earning in dollars and living lavishly on wealth looted by kiiling nirdosh juntaa; and they are playing with nepali bucchabucchi's career by blowing schools; tearing exam papers; etc.
And kewal political parties and king aren;t liable to non-kathmanduites' plight on their lack of cvil amenities. Didn't maoists blow up powerhouses;kill innocent rural teachers and nurses;kidnap businessmen;blast health centres that were existing.
Hey bhawan; india,china,uk,usa lai bhannuss ki one of them comes and annexes nepal and kill all these thugs.
RDX May 5, 2010
I HV SEEN THE WORST SITUATION IN NEPAL. FOR EVERY SMALL OR BIG THEY USE TO CALL STRIKES. PEOPLE IN NEPAL ARE DUMPED HV NO RIGHTS. NO BODY IS CARING ABT BUSINESS STUDIES JUST LOOKING AT THE FRAUD POLITICIANS & SOME LOFERS. COUNTRY FOR LOCAL NEPALIES MEANS NOTHING THEY ARE JUST HELPING THEMSELVES. IF GOVERMENT WANTS TO BECOME STORNG THEY HAVE TO TAKE ACTIONS, THEY SHOULD NOT ALLOW ANY FUTHER DEMOS BY THE MAOISTS IN FACT I WOULD RATHER SAY THEY SHOULD USE GUNS TO KEEP THESE IDOTS QUITE.
XYZ May 5, 2010
@mask
lets talk about this after my exams :-P
I will give you an extended argument of what I actually mean, rather than simply citing my conclusion XD
shikha May 5, 2010
Maoist ko yo so called "PEACEFUL" banda lae saab lai marka ma pareko aaja char din bhayo. Barta huncha tara kunai niskarsha niskadaina, yesto kaile samma sahane ho? Maowadi sarkar kati fitalo thyo ra cha bhanne kura yeslai nai pusti garcha, desh ra janata ko bhanda ni kursi ko moha cha saab political leaders lai.
Kedar May 5, 2010
We are being taken hostage and made guinea pigs to the whims & vested interest of these so called leaders of jana andolan (parties both in government & opposition). We have gone through the painful experience of Rana regime, Panchayat regime and so called democracy / loktantra. God spare us from another experimention of ganatantra.
We are sick & tired of words like bandh, hartal, andolan and so called bhag banda ko rajniti. It has taken us to the failed nation status and to the brink of civil war because of these thugs activities.
Keep up your unbiased reporting and hope against hope that these thugs will come to sense one day and capable of thinking in terms of general public's basic needs.
Annie May 5, 2010
God bless the peaceful long suffering people of Nepal. A country that is beautiful in scenery and spirit.
Hopefully the Maoist will fall flat on the faces, in the dirt of the streets they so cruelly took from the true people of Nepal. Let them have Typhoid but keep it to themselves, it will solve the problem one way.
Unfortunately until all these corrupt and selfish political leaders and people of power, are expelled from their positions, there will be no improvement for this race.
People should not be afraid to walk in their streets and try to feed their families, most survive from day to day. The Maoist care for no-one except themselves, and even some of them will put a strain on their own families wellbeing.
Where are the people of the UN etc, they are sitting watching this country fall apart?
My son and family are Nepali, they assure me they are fine at present but I can tell by the strain in their voices they are worried. Do they have food? My grandson can not go to school! They can not go to work! They must be suffering shortly.
What is happening to the orphaned, destitute and elderly?
And for the person who said the people voted the Maoist party because they want change, most are uneducated and have no idea who can help them,it certainly is not the Maoist party. Some I believe voted the Maoist party on promises they would all become wealthier. I don't think so!!!
My final words will be to say, I love Nepal and it's people but what is happening there today is wrong and harmful to the majority. May a resolution be found truly "PEACEFULLY"
Bashu May 5, 2010
I think it is time that Nepal formulates law banning any disruption of economic and social life by use of force. The law should be such that the leaders of such Bandha (Maoists in this case) should pay the full cost resulting from such disrutpting activity. The court should enforce the law.
If the organizers of such Bandha to refuse or be unable to pay the bill then they should be banned from Running from public office or leading a official party.
aman May 5, 2010
Hi, Its very shameful for Maoists for going strike in nepal.Why u peoples harrasing citizens of nation.if u peoples having trouble with those politicians go and fight with them...show your power there...this is really ridiculous...you all moaist big heads never going to suffer from any thing because u all corrupted peoples having lots of black money...but beware of god...dont u aware of poor peoples who word hard daily and survive? really u peoples never get moksh.Think of development of country..think something good...think good so image of ur nation get big...this type of shameless things only brings bad image of country like nepal an hindu region..just because of all you corrupted minds/
Zanin May 5, 2010
I lerant that Democracy is for the people ,by the people and more so for the countrty....
But what I see is that People are for the so called politicians and by the politicians...
What have they done for the country.. Can anyone name one..?
Yes they are all the parties are good and know how to do Bandha...
I just wonder how come these so called peopledo0 not understand to follow whatever politician say..
All these people are like robot cannot and do not think and cannot stand on their own stand... shame on them.
Maoist and other parties , they are all want the power and once they get power they misuse BIG TIME.
Therefore why do these people are backing them for theose who come and loot your shop and so on.
People shoul be united like maoist and counteract them...
That is what I think one should do.
Know the right thing from the wrong thing then act on it.
mahesh May 5, 2010
For the sake of discussion, Madhav Nepal was brought in by the Maoists themselves, if they thought he was good for nothing then why did they bring him at that time may be just for the sake of being in power at that time. And once he has been instituted as a member of parliament he is free to become and remain the prime minister as far as I can see. If he has lost and still can garner the support of largest party (Maoist) at that time then I see it to be the proff of either his capability or Maoists thirst of power at that time.
All said and done that is past. Regarding the protest as many have pointed out that its a big mass. well it might be a big mass but what does that prove are we going to be govened from the streets. you become the prime minister by the number of person you can bring out on streets by whatever means. If people want to be rule by that philosophy then I do not have anyhting to say on that.
I would rather see Nepal being contracted to other country for 20 years, I think thats the best way.
Politics has always been associated with corruption and with the limited resources we have and half of being lost to the political corruption and nepotism how can development reach to the grass root people Maoists are supposed to cater. So if they really think of the people, they should move towards dissolving multi party democracy and give away the nation to some other contarcors to govern. there is not even a single party that can take Nepal forward.
Nirmal May 5, 2010
Dear Kundu Ji and All comment providers,
The way we expressed here is our common and own opinion. Lets learn to keep ourself over and above this and think. Now time has come each and every Nepali to realize how we can contribute for the country. All these political parties are enjoying our support be it x, y, z parties. We never think our common goal - the development of the country. We can work hard if we are outside and in the country we never think of contributing...and lame excuse is that leaders are corrupt and we cannot do anything.......We made them leaders even we know that they are corrupt and still some of us want to vote for them...everybody here wants to link with some parties and leaders and one day the day will come. Now time has come to think beyond this.
Lets not complain to each other, respect each other but lets have construtive solution...do anyone here have any ideas to share...that will bring peace and prosperity of the country....I think none of us...because we never think beyond our prejudice.....
What is the solution....everybody knows...but why don't you share....we want peace, development and prosperity.....we not all protest... for this with one voice forgetting preconcieved mind of x, y, z parties...
These problems will solved itself.....
Kundu Ji,,, I know you are good journalist...I am big fan of Dr Dixit....the way he thinks.....why don't you try your journalism beyond your preconcieved thinking. You can lead the nation from your pen....put some constructive solution and ideas...and share in your blog....the people like me are here to read these and even to support.....try at once and observe the changes.....
SS May 5, 2010
Bravo Malaya Shahi........Kunda you are no different than the one who paid 2,000 or the one who demanded 5,000 - 50,000
shree5 May 5, 2010
Ive gone thro' al these posting frm top 2 bottom,although wayS of thinking is different but the aim of al our friens were same
"PEACEFUL DEVELOPED NEPAL".
Ive seen alot, Ive passed my golden age in Former USSR.
Absolutely as 1 of our friend wrote,there was lot of similarities betwen families of slaves(general people) & great discremination with BOSS(local & central leaders).
If its posible 2make al Nepali people"LEADER"then communism is best 4 NEPAL,but 4 tht we must afford slaves either internal/extrnal
Weird Mural..!! « i Scribble….. May 5, 2010
[...] other day I was walking to my office [thanks to the peaceful banda imposed by the you know who.] and I saw this huge mural along the way. Normally, I pass this very [...]
shree5 May 5, 2010
Thank you kunda ji to make all different minds to work for same aim.
interesting dialogue between XYZ and mask
disgusting arguements of charle and batti.
hope of john.
nice article of tashi
samagra ma vanda sab nepali haru dherai dherai savye vayeka rahechhan
i m very happy
Dr S Ray May 6, 2010
Mr Dixit writes well but is biased...so its like realding a congress newspaper or UML blog....be a hero...write negative and positive aspects from both the sides so that people can analyse whats wrong and whats right. Why did Maoists win elections with such a huge margin if nobody liked them? I, being from kathmandu, thought the same about maoists few years ago that they were brute and dangerous. Later on i realised they were just same like us. In the rural areas which government had ever provided food , education or health services...was it congress UML or the king..sad to say there was no one...Maoists are the hope of people so they were given won with a huge margin in the elections..everything in maoists is also not right , some top leaders having ego problems. but nevertheless , after analysing for a long time, I think that Dr Baburam bhattarai stands the best to be the next PM of nepal. As a finance minister he had gathered a pretty amount for the developent of the nation ina short time. Makune stands no where. he is a useless PM i support maoist for kicking him out as he is the looser of his own party n the country. Makune should have a little bit pf shame n resign as his government is the worst ever in my view. God Bless Nepal.
da May 6, 2010
Nice to know that at least these many people know that Nepal is heading nowhere- nowhere near a democratic nation. People are fighting not for their needs but wants. Some do not want to give up their positions, some do not want to give up their ideology.
It seems like Maoist is the only party that wants a change. The problem is- either they are a fool not to see the damage done by this bandh OR the Maoist leaders are afraid that they will be beaten to death by their own karyakatras if they take the “jana aandolan III” back. These people are new to politics so for some years we can expect no corruption from them. Who knows how long they can stay away from the lust of “being a neta”. Maoists have good number of constitution assembly member but their main problem is every other person in that assembly is glued with each other to prevent maoists to act. In my view, the maoist leaders are good people who do have good respect and responsibility to the country. BUT the people they gave rise to (like the YLCs) do not have a little bit of good in them. Some are there for just fun, some are too active( like the children in saathdobatto ) who think that they are the leaders and can do anything by using the name of maoist, some are there to make their leaders happy and hope to get good treats( someday). Remaining (and they are “countable”) are the ones who think that this country needs a change. One thing I feel disappointed with Maoists is they always said “ maoist can do this”, “maoist can do that”. They never said “we people need to do that”, they never represented the people but their party.
Our Prime Minister Ma.Ku.Ne ji SPOKE to PEOPLE on the national television! What he spoke sounded like a neta speaking against his opposition during election campaign- he did not speak to people. He thinks he is the humanitarian, “loved by people” kind of person. May be he forgot that he was voted out from 2 place; one was his own hometown. First do good, and then expect other to do so. Sometimes I feel he should be given Nobel Peace Prize- he is so peaceful; never does anything- good nor bad-just watches bananas. Mr. Baamdev Gautam (……how quickly these politicians find the way to profit themselves??!!) came asking for the prime minister’s resign…so sweet of u!! It does not shoot u being that good. Late Giraja babu was no better to these. The best possible thing we could have done would have been saying “Prachanda ji ….. 4 mahenaa hajur khanu, 4 mahina madhab ji khanu huncha, bachko 4 maina meri chori le khanche”. He became prime minister for 5 times. Only thing that changed was the sarkar and another blood sucker rose to power.
We are the ones to blame. We want our relatives to win a ticket so we can get help when we are needy. We want to choose the party who will favour us. We never thought that there are 30 million people outside our houses. Every son wants his father to corrupt so he can buy the new playstation- every wife wants his husband to earn underhand so she can buy a new, bigger jewelry. No one needs communism – no one needs democracy. We don’t need our party rule the country. We don’t even need a party. We need change; that’s true but not the change in government; we need change in attitude, change in mindset, a change in us. What we need is “the sincirity”. And a bandh can in no way put that inside us.
Sabin S May 6, 2010
You people so called journalists, human right activists, civic leaders are also responsible for this current mess. You people made currupt Giriza as the hero of Jana Andolan 2 who is responsible for the most part as of current mess. You people endorsed for Indian Sponsored Jana Andolan as the way out for democracy which has nothing but to colonize Nepal in mind. Also, it was the strategy of Party leaders as to get back into power. You people labeled them as hero for Loktantra, the word was also borrowed from India. It is absurd that, you did not see anything when the Maoists were using the same technique to force people to participate in JA2, and force for Chanda. You people never bothered for a fact check. May be you just kept blind eye for the shake so called "Loktantra". Now you have seen the result. People are tired of not only the corrupt leaders but also of corrupt views of your which is/was misleading, biased and worthless. People are judging now.
Annie May 6, 2010
Shame on you Bhatti
Bjorn May 6, 2010
Dear people of Nepal of all political conviction. Your country is beautiful, your people kind. We tourist like to come here and help your economy and enjoy your precense at the same time. Whatever is happening now does not help you (without taking a political view, for that I am not informed enough). Most foreign governments are considering right now a negative travel advice on Nepal. This means foreigners are likely not to come to you, if this unrest continues. This will be a huge loss of income and a loss of enrichment both for you and foreigners who like sharing their time with you beautiful people. Keep talking, keep striving for improvement but don't use violence or have the strike affect public life completely. I heard Thailand was a source of inspiration and example. I just came from Thailand. The protest is concentrated in a couple of areas of the city of Bangkok whereas other areas remain unaffected. It does not stop the country from functioning and it is not threathening. If it will be used as an example, I hope it will be used properly. This situation is not comparable to Thailand. I hope it will all turn out well and trust everyone of each conviction will take the best decisions for Nepal. Best regards, Bjorn
Janata May 6, 2010
On the 7th of May, Friday at 9 am from Basantapur,
FNCCI, Nepal Chamber of Commerce, PAPAD and other non political organizations are organizing a peace rally to oppose the Bandh.
Please join us. Let us show our strength and solidarity to defend our democratic rights.
Devendra Pant May 6, 2010
Mr. Dixit's article portrays that banda has blind-folded everything. Even the conscience of the Nation seems imprisoned in banda at this hour. Today, Nepal reminds me of not only banda but also led by a bunch of the "blind". Once poet Bhupi Sherchan's famously satirized-- "ghumne mech maathiko andho maanche" (the blind man locked in (banda) the revolving chair). Yes, the power elite ceases to " see" anything beyond kurshiko unmaat!! On the other hand, those protesting seem to be increasingly locked in impasse (blinded and in banda!) as well. Depicting the harsh winter of KTM, poet Lekh Nath Poudyal satirized-- "gale-banda bhaye sabai" (the stanza has double meanings, first, all have been tired of and shut down the shutters; second; all putting on mufflers to protect from the wind chill). In either meaning, today, people's dream for democracy seems to have turned into an eternal winter of discontent. Everybody is tired of political tamasa and fiasco in KTM! It seems the historic trust people put in Nepal's leaders and Constituent Assembly has been put in bandaki. One wonders how many more jana andolan this country needs to be put on the right path to prosperity and democracy. According to Vladimir Lenin a perfect condition for revolution is-- "The top (elite) do not want to give up (power), the bottom (downtrodden) do not want to live (by the old rules)! ". On the other hand, John Lennon in his famous lyrics says-- "You want a revolution, but we want change!" The question is which way to go forward-- Lennon or Lenin? Perhaps, this time one needs aandolan not for the people but for the transformation of political culture in KTM.
PaisaKamaoUlluBanao May 6, 2010
Kundan knows professional writing similar to those political leaders talking cheap bullshits. The writer is highly biased, influenced and prejudiced minded and well trained to express the events like a shopkeeper selling momos mixing mutton with buff but charging the rate at mutton's.
kesarsing jhankri May 6, 2010
This protest is meaningless and senseless.The Maoists themselve wrote interim-constituation and they are very who dot not follows. Some people say Mr Madhav is inable to be the PM but that is his obligation after Maoist abandoned the post for not meeting their selfish interest.So why the maoist to envy him? Who blocked their Prachande to be PM by proving the majority in the parliament? As maoist is the largest party in the parliament they have the morale responsibility to convince and take other smaller parties.instead they are fighting against them; like a big brother is fighting with his yongers! So, the maoist must stop terrorising and harassing the peoples.
Sudip May 6, 2010
I have been forced to walk 7 km a day to my daily work and I have found many a people as company walking and suffering from the so called movement to free people from suffering.
We have seen the nine months government of the Maoists and also the so called revolutionary changes I am sorry for all the people who still rally behind the Maoist.
The only change that Maoists will bring is the change of the government.To me Pra-chanda sounds so much in same tone as Pol-Pott.
Ratna Shasendra May 6, 2010
In democratic countries, to strike is a fundamental right that was hard fought for.
But it is never an obligation and should never be!
This is totally again the fundamental principles of democracy than to impose upon other people to strike.
How could striking be a genuine testimony of people's discontent if they are forced to strike under threat? This actually backfire: people become discontent with those who called the strike and consider them as totalitarian brutes, not democrats
Pramesh Shrestha May 6, 2010
This comment has been removed by the moderator.
Mike May 6, 2010
“Peaceful” Aandolan
One more pedestrian
One more poor
One more out of job
One more without care
Is it fair?
One more neta
Few less praja
Smiles one
Smirks another
Cry out a few
No one listens
Does anyone care?
Someone hungry
And sleepless
Another angry
Yet another in pain
All over “krantikari” rein
Dear Lord!
We don’t need Aandolan
Nor such Peaceful means
I seek
A normal day
And an ordinary chore
From this "Kranti"
Do I dare ask for more?
Uttam May 6, 2010
The Maoist have shown that they have tremendous support from the majority of the people in Nepal, a country which is mostly populated with poor people. They have shown that they hold the power to shut down an entire country. But by shutting down the lives of the ordinary people the Maoist will lose support from all the people that have had their lives shut down since May 1. It is time for the Maoist to call off the shut-down of the lives of ordinary people and focus all their attention on shutting-down the government instead in order for them to succeed in achieving their goal. They should begin blockading all government offices and residences of all top government officials to bring down the government which is headed by a PM who was not elected by the people of Nepal to serve in the CA - no leader has the right to serve as PM unless he/she is elected by the people in a democracy. If the Maoists don't change their tactics immediately their movement will start to lose support from the people and the movement will not succeed.
Clarity May 6, 2010
When one percieves himself or herself as torch bearer- what he preaches is always flawed. This sydrome is with Mr. Dixit. He places bet as change in the wind. I have no respect for his kind. He jumped on wangon back in Andolan 2 without the care in the world where its gonna land. He preached and hob nobbed with people to further his interest rather than a nation. Whatever he writes is not worth an eye as he is morally, professionally, and ethically compromised
annoyed May 6, 2010
Well written. To all the haters, didn't Prachanda step down as the Prime Minister without anyone asking him to? If he was so concerned, why did he step down, if he wants to get back in office so bad, what was the point in getting out of office? This bandh is just mind numbingly senseless. If the maoists believe that they are doing something "for the people", keeping people out of work for 5 straight days and not letting them earn their living is not doing something "for" the people.
People aren't getting anything in return. As kids bandhs used to be fun, school would be closed, you could go out on the street and play cricket, but we were kids, what better did we know, we lapped up every excuse we had to not go to school with utter enjoyment. Once you're older, you realize how utterly pointless those things were. Make a point, host a rally, walk around for an hour or two, noone will complain about that, but 5 days of this is insane.
Do the people on the street realize what's going on, or are they really that brainwashed? The peaceful andolan that they are trying to hold has succumbed to vandalizing and asking poor shop owners to pay for their expenses. If the maoists invited everyone from different places to attended this damned andolan, shouldn't they be the one providing for all these people. It is not polite nor is it smart to try to force everyone to join their movement. They have no right of telling hotel owners to feed their people and paying a sixth of what something costs. These are the same people they are supposed to be working for. These are the same people that are apparently oppressed and according to you need your help, oh wise maoists.
Open your window and smell the damn air, there's disgust and there's arrogance. There's idiocity and there's utter brainlessness. Just look at yourselves out on the streets, while you enjoyed sleeping on a hard surface cramped with 10 of your other fellow protesteors, im sure your leaders were snuggled up on their own comfortable beds next to their spouse catching up on their favorite soap opera. Just think for a second, it does not take too long to understand what's right and what's wrong, and it shouldn't even take longer to realize that what you are doing is just insanely dumb.
again, a very well written piece kunda ji, enjoyed it...keep truckin' along on that bicycle!
Krantiman May 6, 2010
Dear Kunda,
Long time no see. Read your peaceful maoist banda in your blog. It is indeed a wonderfully peaceful banda, staging drama, drumming, singing, dancing, chanting, with, off course, some shouting, coercion, extorting, intimidating, torching, abusing, but certainly not looting, robbing, destroying, vandalizing, kidnapping, torchering and killing. It is probably an improvement over the situation preceeding andolan 2. There are some sign of civility we can see in the present andolan.
Whatever is the logic thrown, I am sorry, I see no logic in this andolan. It is like an admant juvenile pressing for a toy he sees with another child. Or like a crazy boy opting to jump from the window to get hold of a ball in the lawn, instead of rushing down the stares. There is absolutely no need to create such tension out of nothing and disturb the already fragile social harmony and economic activities.
Our learned Andolankaries need to have patient and work in harmony for the common good and progress. They should understand that the work-force that they drew to this disturbing andolan could better be put to more productive uses in farming, industries and trade. This way, may be, we will be able to fast-forward building Singapore here in next twenty years, thirty years faster than Singapore itself did.
I wonder what five days of andolan brought to us, except more problem, mis-understanding and misery, pushing us all to more complications and poverty. We are all Nepalese brothers and sisters, not aliens. We can live together like a family. If Andolan can destroy us, we can use the same force to make our administrative machinaries work efficiently, absorb our workforce to employment, use up all our installed capacities and produce all our food, drink and exports. We only need good intent and honesty; tolerance and harmony, not ego and strife; will to work, not evase and cheat. Thank you.
Buff May 6, 2010
Got the privilege to hear this joke, or rather a humiliating joke from a cabbie!
Somewhere in the farms of Indian subcontinent lived a herd of buffaloes.
A trader bought a bunch of buffaloes and put them in a truck.
The one of the buffaloes in the truck asked another one, “Where are we off to?” The other replied, “Hardai Jaun, Dekhdai Jaun, Why worry?”
The Buffaloes who were still in the farm told one another, “Thank god, it is them and not us! Look at them being stuffed into that truck!”
Their journey to the unknown began. The Buffaloes in the truck enjoyed peeping out. They were amazed at the wide open roads, properly segregated “Grass Zone”. But they did complain that it was really hot and stuffy in the truck.
Days passed and the truck began the uphill ascent. The buffaloes began to enjoy the chilly yet pleasant weather coupled with a beautiful view of free meandering river below.
The one of the buffaloes in the truck again asked the other, “Where are we off to?” The other replied, “Chup Lag na...Hardai Jaun, Dekhdai Jaun, Why worry?”
The Truck then came to a screeching halt in a grassy land surrounded by mountains. The buffaloes were unloaded and tied to a pole.
One Smart A$$ buffalo asked the other, “Where are we?” The other (equally smart, if not smarter) replied, “Mausam ta Ramrao cha, Even the Grass tastes weirdly good...Hardai Jaun, Dekhdai Jaun, Why worry?”
Then came B-Day.
Much to the delight of the buffaloes, a man came up to them wielding a fascinating, sharp toy, and took Buffy, the buffalo to a corner.
The other buffaloes murmured, “How Lucky!”
The man tied Buffy’s legs, pinned him down and pushed the fascinating toy straight down Buffy’s gullet.
One of the other Buffaloes, filled with remorse and chagrin, shouted out, “Hey Bhagwaan! Ke Gardeko!!”
The other buffalo replied, “Chup lag!.. They might hear you! Thank god it ain’t us! Ail eta, Hardai Jaun, Dekhdai Jaun, Why worry?”
All the surviving buffaloes nodded their heads in unison and to began munch the green, green grass!
We’re just a bunch of Buffaloes, baby! We suck! Big Time!
PS. Menu for tomorrow: Delicate tire burning topped with exotic bricks along with a free ticket to doom!
observer May 6, 2010
Please delete my above post:
I made some typos so this is the edited version.
I am amazed at how educated class does not seem to posess any kind of objectivity. I am not saying that you need to support the Maobadis or the kangresis, why can't we have an objective perspective on this. Of course you can pick sides but its easier to stay at home and watch it on television. For once, lets reflect on ourselves and think about why Nepal is where it is.
We talk abut how nepal being doomed and there is no future. Well if you think so please leave the country.Someone said something like, Nepal should be made part of India. Excuse me is that your solution? How can you even think like that ? Sure, we have problems, every country has had problems, How dare you equate us to another country. If you're so wiling to join forces with india, we know where your patriotism lies or not. If not start doing something .
You don't need to start a movement, a great revolutionary movement. We always talk about the fact that the leaders have been horrible, they're power hungry, corrupt etc. But have we ever stopped and thought, how did they reach this stage. Every one of us is responsible for where the state is. Simple things like, you drive without a license, when you're caught, and yet you're ready to give "khaja khane paisa' to the traffic police Every single nepali is responsible for getting Nepal where it is.
Our urban youth who are supposed to be the future intellectuals, people who change the country know what's going on in Britany Spears' life but say "politics is a dirty game, i won't get involved in it." They would rather possess an iphone and other commodities but will chose to turn a blind eye to the chaos that is surrounding them.
Have we every protested about things like professors need to show up at TU on time and teach well, not finish the syllabus 3 months in advance. All of us knew that the banda would take place. Why did we wait until, its crippled us to complain about it.
So before we make all these great statements about how none of the leaders take responsibility for our action, let's look at ourselves in the mirror and think how as a nepali citizens, we've never taken responsibility for our actions. We always shift the blame on to someone else.
We will not hesitate to bend the rules at any given point of time given if it benefits us.
Yet we make these statements regarding how our country has turned into shambles,
it has but who is to blame?
Sanjib May 6, 2010
Thank you Kunda dai, tapaile dekheko ramrari capture garnubhayeko rahechha....
Apil Dev Neupane May 6, 2010
Why is Mr. Kunda not responding to so many Question put here?
w May 6, 2010
The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good people to do nothing -
Edmund Burke
Hope to see you tomorrow at Basantapur.
w May 6, 2010
I heard now the peace rally has been postponed at the behest of politicans. Maybe a deal is on.
w May 7, 2010
Now we have to go as I heard the maos have thretened FNCCI memebers not to take out the rally. But this is just why we have to go.
P. May 7, 2010
I see nearly the same you do.
Our society and the nation is perhaps at the most critical bottlenecks of history. We very urgently need some (definitely not one) who could play instrumental role in breaking a deal.
We are perhaps preparing for a full blown more chaos, confrontations and a civil war.
If we could calm ourselves, we still do have a big prospect. But if not, distress, tears, tears and more tears.
Norm May 7, 2010
@ Mask @ XYZ i am really suprised as to how people in this 21st even contemplate socialism and communism. Its not about failed in history or how to implement this fossilized concepts. Its about being able to trade in capital markets with the globe today. If nepal is ever to do that it has to be ... and i stress IT HAS TO BE a democratic free market economy, timely regulated with the help of the IMF and the other developed worlds. Please dont even think that Socialism has a middle path, i know India I have read India and i know exactly how its suffering from socialist side effects. If you guys havent been living in a mud hut for the past 50 years, capitalism with a liberal and free economy is the future and will remain so for the next century....
Sheela May 7, 2010
Mr. Kund,
I happend to read your 'vomit' against maoist in Nepal. You deserve to save your elite clase of people, which Maoist intend to over turn over. But is this the right time to go to dead against of any patritic forces like Maoist in Nepal!
Kunda jee, forget you suprimo-class for the noble cause of matri-bhoomi, later you can fight with Maoist to serve your capital-class when we are free from Indian semi-colonization!
Wake -up Kund jee before it become too late! otherwise join Hindi learning institution somewhere at bagbajaar for your next easy communication!
joshi May 7, 2010
Well...well.. we all Nepalese, always have high hope in any change in the country. We have put our life in hope of peace and stability during Jana Andolan and dethroned king. It will always be best part of my life. At the same time, I never had faith in any politicians. From Terrorist prachanda, corrupt Madhav Nepal, Sujata Koirala, Ram Chandra Poudel, Oli, Deuba and many more present day politicians. Infact they put theirs and family interest first and people at last. Is there anyone who have put country and people first? It is heart paining to see general people suffering from these scumbags behaviour. These politicians sons and daughters went overseas for higher studies with our tax money. Our sons and daughter even couldn't attend schools with peace. What else can we expect from these fucking idiots.......But I know we all Love Nepal and all should be ready when need comes ready to go against these NC...Maobadi, UML over all politicians.
Meantime, lets Pray to God for Peace.
dinesh May 7, 2010
congrats. your writing is giving people exact representation situation. I do not see lack of educated person in Maoist leadership positions, they are organized but their talent and strengths are not channelized towards positively energizing people . rather they are spending energy to make people fool themselves under their leadership. My humble suggestions is Oh! Maoist leaders, use your strengths and talents to make country towards real real world not an imaginary world where you can not achieve. we appreciate you have revolutionized various aspects , but now you are going to wrong direction, may be you have some problem within your party who see Nepal as 50 years back and internationalization of movement and employment have been a changing force, you know, within no time communication is happening, BE 21ST CENTURY LEADER NOT LATE 19TH AND 20 TH CENTURY LEADER.
tony prety May 7, 2010
dear kunda,
i would say that who the hell in the world has given the right to prachanda, baburam and their puchar (followers) to dictate the basic and fundamental rights of all nepali citizens. are they that god who tells to all nepalese to follow theri order otherwise they are subjected to thir bhautik karbhai (physical punishment)? who are these people who has the right to take away my right to live, right to earn, right to carry on my occupation, right to open my shop, right to ride my bike or vehicle, right to go to market, right to sell my goods, right to go to hospital, right to go to school, right to send my kids to school, right to take my old and sick father to hospital, right to pray to god that i choose, and many more. it is absolutly unacceptable to take all nepalese rights away for their selfish, narrow and undefined ideology. nobody had forced prachanda to resign from his post and no nepalese should be taken hostage just because he would like to get back his post. at this point all nepalese have become prisoners inside their own house. they should be freed politicians should leave them alone. nepalese shoudl not be subjected to black mail, extortion, forced participation, forced to feed some one who you do not even know and forced to moaist interest. if politicians can not write the constitution of nepal then somebody else should be given this responsibility. i could have prepared this document within a month at the most. we need new, young, vibrant, and a nepali leader but not certainly the one who came from foreign soil and scares all nepalese off with pressuer cooker bomb and bhautik karbhai. keep up the good work kunda.
Annie May 7, 2010
What is needed is a Politican,Person who can stand up and say "Enough". They need to get the people of Nepal and the world to sit up and listen. One who is not corrupt, selfish and arrogant.
Somewhere in your great country there is such a person. A person of strength and courage, who will lead Nepal to a better life. You need to find that person. There has to be a true Political leader amongst your nations people, not like the ones that you have had for the last few years.
I pray the people of Nepal can find this person, and soon.
Nepal has the ability to be a rich and wealthy country if the right person is found.
Urban Rebel May 7, 2010
Aite! Aite !Aite! Enough of crap. You love Nepal? Come to the streets, join the rally. Protest! Show everyone what we are. All MITs and Oxfords and Harvards - get your shoes dirty, for once decide what you want and make it happen. Don't just sit in your room and type.. "this should happen and that should happen". All those chickens... living ABROAD... don't even type.. you don't belong to Nepal.. so SHUT UP. We will do what we have to. One guy wrote "I say I am from Asia" .. good... You didn't say Nepal coz you don't have the right mate... So buzz off.
It's not yet over people! Nepal is not yet shattered! It's now time to change. Choose who is right and who is wrong. If all the parties are wrong.. let a new one rise!
Come Join the rally... don't wait for Madan Krisna Hari Bansa to go "eieieie" .. we don't have time for that... If this is your Kathmandu.. drive the corrupts out of here... If this is your Nepal.. drive the corrupts out of here.. LETS GO!!
kirtipure May 7, 2010
Dear Kunda, you are in the right track based on your profession, social classes, and ideology. Everybody knows about you and your family business. KEEP IT UP, TRY TO VOMIT AS MUCH AS POSSIBLE.
Nostradamus May 7, 2010
...the hope for Nepal is to bring leaders like Gagan Thapa to the fore ..... he has the capacity to lead Nepal to better grounds....
Narendra May 7, 2010
It is very unfortunate that our leaders in Nepal are very short-sighted. They don't understand the dialects of civil society. What I see here is a poor handling and mismanagement on the part of our current Government for letting the situations come to this end. This Government should be held accountable.
People don't go to such extent for fun, obviously they felt they haven't been heard, addressed so they have hit the road.
Kunda, you have surely succeeded to enlist the misery of people in current situation but cleverly forgot to mention the hardship faced by the "demonstrators" themselves. What we should not forget here is that they are also part of our society, our fellow countrymen/women. Hence I would say your portraying the situation is only a biased copy-cat. No offence meant.
Nick Sharma May 7, 2010
For once, Mr. Dixit- please see the writing on the wall. 7 days of peaceful strike ( by the Home Minister's own admission)- from Mechi to Mahakali and not just Kathmandu and you still think it's not a peoples' movement???
Mahesh May 7, 2010
Mr. Dixit.
We are all getting it wrong, in fact, the culture of Bandha's is a test tube concept thrown on us by the Powers To Be to save our planet and the Himalayas in particular from the clutches of climate change and what better way to do it other then calling it a peaceful protest. But, you cannot deny the benefits of a healthy bycycle ride amidst a non-existing crazy traffic of Kathmandu as the small gains of this Bandha - not forgetting the sizeable quantity of fossil fuels we might be saving and the resultant clean air everybody is breathing. I am sure the think-tanks of other Green Parties the world over are working overtime to measure this effect of Peacefull Bandh's on our Planet Earth.
In the meanwhile cheers and blessings to a few more days of inconvenience to all our benign and simple Nepalese who are famous for being taken for a ride.....
Bashu May 7, 2010
Will anyone put hands up to address Annie's comments. What about GAGAN THAPA.. this man should be speaking up now. He should stand when all of the Nepaleses' basic right are being snatch away for straight 6 days by a party with totalitarian spine.
Pramesh not now in Nepal May 7, 2010
1. Let neighbours and world powers negotiate us.
or
2. Let us fight like Sri Lankan.
Our choice
Jana andolan May 7, 2010
It is not a peaceful bandh. It is just like a curfew. Maoist cadres are moving freely in the streets with weapon. You can not walk and talk whereever you like to walk or talk.
Maoist has captured the colleges and schools and they are making these schools and colleges as a paramilitary camps.
MASK May 7, 2010
@Norm : Glad to know that you have been reading :-)...
"Its not about failed in history or how to implement this fossilized concepts. Its about being able to trade in capital markets with the globe today. " - Fossilized concept.. he he. True but what is not mate? Capitalism?
"If nepal is ever to do that it has to be … and i stress IT HAS TO BE a democratic free market economy"- Well my friend you need to reread my comments, if you had read well you would have understood , democracy has nothing to do with socialism and communism.
"If you guys havent been living in a mud hut for the past 50 years, capitalism with a liberal and free economy is the future and will remain so for the next century" - I am just 27 years of age, so past 27 years living in MUD HUT and not 50, i dont know XYZ's age and if he is been living in MUD HUT, ask him. Measuring your words you must be a very rich guy.
" i know India I have read India and i know exactly how its suffering from socialist side effects" - That must have taken a you along time.. you must be 50 i suppose :-)
Anways people always have a difference of opinion, and i am not here to change it. The fact is even if you collect the worlds welath and distribute a share equally to each individual, after 10 years you will again have people who are rich and people who are poor, as everyone doesnt understand money and those who understand are rich those who doesnt are poor, and you must be the one who understands and that why you must be rich..lol.
Apologizes for not being aligned with the topic..
kancha May 7, 2010
THINK THINK THINK THINK
Who are these people?
What do they want?
Do they want politician in this country?
Do you think, these people are not familiar with ism and ideology?
Do they wants to eat without doing any work?
Do they need any allowance without doing any job?
Do they ask donation from you?
Do they create any pressure to you, come down to the street?
Are they coming here to say give money to my CADRE ?
Our Country is Very Beautiful with Honest people BUT In the name of political leader all of they are fox and try to finish our honesty. JUST HATE THEM. JUST HATE THEM.
I THINK THIS IS NOT FUNERAL CEREMONY… NEPALI POLITICIAN SHOULD THINK.
Bhava Nath May 7, 2010
We have single road- peace to peace not piece to piece.
Tom May 7, 2010
Well written article. But the article you have written on "peacefull bandh" and most of the responses made to it are now becoming gradually irrelevant as the country has already become half a janagantrantrik Nepal. Thanks to Girja babu- a born communist and died also as a great communist - who successfully who led the most glorious revolution of transforming Prajantraric Nepal to half a Janagantrantrik Nepal in the guise of " Sanghia Loktrantrik Nepal". Maoist, taking of the previledges of 12 Points agreement are utilizing both jan sena and YCL to make not only the bandhs but also the remaining job of bringing a full-fleged janagantranta the most peaceful events . Given the ongoing unhindered activities of extortion, conversion of school and party palaces to make-shift dorms and many other similar activities; Government, congress and UML and other parties are boldly fulfilling their reponisibility as brave spectators in this process.
Help the Maoist to make this bandh more peacefull by by peacefully and obidently following their diktats- give donations, close your business and shop etc, you are helping the Maoist not only to bring down the government from the streets and also to bring about a jana ganatantrik constitution in Nepal. Once the jana ganatantrik constitution takes its effects, take my words , this country does not need any further bandh because that constitution on its own is solution to all probems. Come the janaganatantrik constitution in Nepal not only your article but any other articles on bandh will be completely irrelelvant for once and all .
subs May 7, 2010
incorrect labelling of 'peacful' bhanda is dishonest. its important to express dissatifaction but incorrect to forceful people to join them unwillingly. I think the maoist leaders should read mahatma ghandi's autobiography throughly (as there is a danger of misunderstanding) then pratise it properly, if they want to label it "peaceful"
rajesh May 7, 2010
I feel very pity on the guys who still are boasting something nounsense that, " WE ARE THE SONS OF GORKHALIS". So, where is that sprit when it comes to use it?
What are you doing guys/junkies? You use to be heroes of your area; now that all has gone to hell and have now been accustomed to confined in your area and in your room just like a rat?
Where is your attitude to fight back to something wrong?
Annie May 7, 2010
To dear Urban Rebel,
We are not allowed at present to book flights to Nepal, which Yes is your country. Be glad that people in the world care enough to at least address this problem in any way they can.
No I am not Nepalese, I am Australian but I have family in Kathmandu, whom are Nepali and whom I love dearly, so do not tell me or the others to SHUT-UP.
If you actually read my blog, it said to find the person who can help Nepal, and by the way, violence is not a solution.
rise up May 7, 2010
GAGAN THAPA------ DONT SLEEP!!!!! RISE UP
ratna May 8, 2010
desle yadi change chaheko chha vane yo anayitik haruwaharuharuko jambo sarkarko hatnu nayi ho..
hunata kohi pani tyahti var pardo ta chhayina. tar k garnu yasta khachhad makuneharuko sarkar hunu vanda ta banda garer dhalnu nayi thik chha.
a supporter of democracy May 8, 2010
Well Kunda ji -- it was Himal, yourself and your brother Kanak ji who gave so much importance to Maoist movement, and in fact, even supported their cause. There is a Nepali proverb - Challa khane le, mau pani khanchha -- this is what happened now. Instead trying to bring the king and parties together, you were in pursuit of bringing parties and maoists which removed the monarchy (this does not mean I am supporting monarchy but I think was a necessary devil to protect democracy). You must have now realized the maoist intention. They were just playing with people like you to eventually establish communism. We all have to suffer now. I hope you will take my observation in good spirit. Thanks.
WAIBA May 8, 2010
its not unusual! its so simple becoz you cannot expect to see Buddha/Gandhi in Prachanda! Threatening, Torture, Forceful Acts, etc. all fall under peaceful means while violence only reflects to death/murder in the dictionary of Dr. Baburam Bhattarai! so cool down everybody, its the culture of BASTARDS!!!! or if you have GUTS challenge these bastards!
gg May 8, 2010
tapain thula raja ki sana raja re??
P Norbu May 8, 2010
My heart aches for the people of Nepal and for those miss-guided youths (so-called Maoist cadre) who are being used as means/ways to get to the power! Our present coalition leaderships is nothing but a bunch of morons who failed to bring about the changes that public expected them to. All they have brought is confusion and indecisiveness. And the ones in opposition (Maoist) are meddling just to unseat the present government so that they can intimidate and dictate general public once they are in power!! The ongoing protest rallies are an example of it!
To be very frank, all these political leaders are here for power and money regardless of party affiliation. You can judge that by rampant corruption in Nepal - corruption of power, system and law/order. Where did the MILLIONS of dollars that have been poured in by donor countries and other aid groups go? To the 16 hours of load shedding? To the jobless youths on the city streets? To countless potholes in the city street of ktm? Or to the roofless school buildings in the villages? Any doubt where iwent? Um..Into the deep pockets of those corrupt leaders (left and right)!!
We have all heard parties preaching national unity and good governance. But in reality, all they have been doing is preaching their own party doctrines to further their goal of getting to power! Wish our political leaders are that persistent in uplifting the lives of the poor in remote villages. Why cant Nepal be a place where all have equal opportunities and where people can live in peace? Too much of the dirty politics has destroyed the positive vibe that we got after the democratic revolution.
Even our judicial system is neither reliable nor independent. Courts - Punish the corrupts political leaders and fix the broken system. When will our youngs/youths use their heads and start walking away from all these politically clogged groups like YCL and other so-called youth wings? Future of our country depends on, if and when our youths take not just active but pro-active role in bringing about the social changes that is necessary. We need to work for a stable government with sustainable policies which could serve the general public. So, I urge our youths, not to run after bunch of morons/goons (political leaders) like a bull running after anything that is red!!
Though a Tibetan (non-citizen), it's still my home away from home and I always wish it well.
Rabi Chamling Rai May 8, 2010
too many mixed reactions.. i believe it's bcoz u're too anti-maoist.. that i believe is also unprofessional of u.. lets try giving the story from both sides..
Bashu Arya May 8, 2010
I agree with Anne. I am Nepal born Australian. I do love the contry of birth and contributing in many ways through financial donations to charity organisation and providing training to Nepal's technical work force.
People like Anne and I (all over the world) think we are bound by heart to say what is wrong or right in Nepal (say catastrophic event like the current Bandha) as we want to see Nepal become prosperous and that people lead a peaceful life.
Annie May 8, 2010
Maybe Gagan Thapa is the answer, I hope so. He is young, fresh and intelligent.
Deva May 9, 2010
The address by Prachanda today in the open air stadium was an open threat to all the affluent people of Kathmandu who took part in yesterday's Durbar Square rally. His rantings reminded me of another such personality, Adolf Hitler!
If the people of this country do not unite and oppose this growing threat, we are doomed for another couple of decades, and the country will be headed towards a terrible future!
Mao May 9, 2010
Prachanda's speech today was what Mao would have called "strategic retreat" the Maoists have retreated due to domestic and international pressure, but have in now way changed their spots. they have pinpointed where the weakness of the present movement were, who were the main organisers of the resistance and next time will be even more ruthless. It's time to nip this in the bud. They are Gang of Four Maoists, not Deng Xiao-ping Maoists.
omg May 9, 2010
This comment has been removed by the moderator.
Mohan May 9, 2010
I savored this read.
dhanu May 9, 2010
well, no day without night! what I can say is , Our country is infected with a kind of deasis..and this Generation (i.e. US) should find out the perfect cure for that. I think the question now is standing not about moist or some others..but the fact that our country is verymuch in need of "NEPALI LEADER" and not all these pirates..I dont think that the present disturbations took place suddenly, but this is the mistake that has been done 30 to 20 years before. Our Nepal needs to be educated first to cope up with todays world and which is not that easy that we all know. lata ko des ma gara tandari..in uneducated country we are searching perfect leader which is not that easy job unfurtunetly.
Madhu May 9, 2010
He really reminds us of Hitler. With Gestapo and Goebles.
ashish May 9, 2010
bad bad bad so bad lots of people die, lost their, relatives , home by thinking that we will get peace but leader dont think so ; the divide people into tow group and use for their own shake ; some to be primeminister some to make ther periode long as possible as so its to bad . leader do not follow rules which they make and is it necessary to folloe it by common people why .did prachanda suffer from dihira, did he got any stick ,stone in his body.
Prachanda kukur ho May 9, 2010
Well, where are the so called Human rights and 'the re conciliator' .. the great facilitator Padma Ratna Tuladhar now ? Why are all of them silent ? Either afraid or they are on Maoist looted money payroll. I hope you realize your own mistake of feeding the snakes Kunda ji.
Now every one seems to be happy that the Maoists took back the banda ... (they have shown mercy upon us, the wretched souls !). I think this is the lack of defiance in Nepalis, that makes us subservient to whoever is in power, first it was monarchy and now it is Maoists. Despite everyone's resentment against them, all seem to be holding themselves back not to criticise, lest they have to face the wrath of maoists... I can understand the fear.. but Ma Ha's confession that Maoists were so great because they took back their banda... is so hypocritical. They used to represent defiance in the monarchila times... Looks like they've grown old now ! Sadly..
sandesha May 10, 2010
This comment has been removed by the moderator.
Nepali May 10, 2010
Mr. Dixit,
I hope you have a piece of press freedom now... you had well supported Mao's .. please take your stand and believe in proper democracy. you along with other so called part time communist are responsible for this situation as well.
Dr. Neupane May 10, 2010
A grossly illusory and amblyopic vision of a person considered to be one of the finest journalists in Nepal. Shame on you, Mr. Dixit!
Devendra Yadav May 10, 2010
Hi Kunda,
Thanks for the touching and true analysis of the on going problem. Really its honest explanation but here only the problem doesnt stop and here only ur analysis shouldnt stopped.in reality the nation and the people today need the solution not the analysis of the problem. in my opinion being the proud citizen of the country this is the tasting time where we need to prove that we are the real son of this nation and its our nation.So its my humble request to the true nationalist to come out with the opinion of solution and save the nation.
Thanks and Regards,
Devendra yadav
@PRadyumna May 10, 2010
1. People wanted change after 2nd janaandolan.
here change is a vague term ... change like what? and has it happened or even the political parties have thought about it .. naya nepal vaneko ta desh tukarney vako cha..... i just want sundar shant NEPAL
2.People ( as seen) voted maoists as a largest party, with the hope of change come true..
haha aru party ko karyakarta kutney, khutta vachney, gaun gaun ma jabarjasti vote dina launey (was it fair)
in cities I do believe ppl vote to see what maoists are made of
3. Madhav Nepal has been rejected as a good leader by majority of people, they never want Mr. Nepal to be a PM.
Prachanda was the main reason Makuney is now PM
4. Madhav Nepal does not deserve to be PM and his being PM is against the people’s wish of change.
people has nothing to do with it ... all the taukeys chose him
5.Madhav Nepal knows very well, this is the ending of his time in politics, after he resign, he will be lost from whole political scene.
i think u hav personal issues with emaley
6. Madhav Nepal never wants to resign from post.
Who does? Prachanda? Sher bdr deuba? all are same
7. People’s verdict goes against Madhav Nepal and if people stay silent, why would Ma Ne Resign?
it was clear already that people dont want Makuney ....
8.So, people said, Madhav Nepal,you are not our choice..but no one would hear that.
as if maoists listened to our pleas to stop hatya and hinsa
9. That is pity in Nepal, untill and unless there is a bang, no one would give attention to it.
U r YCL (Young Criminal League) ......... 100% proven
10. So after a year, if maoists are trying to create that bang and take out Madhav Nepal, that is fine. Why do we support Madhav Nepal who cant bring change, who has lost election ?
Prachanda could not handle the pressure or there was something inside... people have not supported Makuney
11. If you have any solid ideas on how to take MAdhav Nepal out and restore the multi party government matching with people’s verdict, tell it to media, tell it to people. Else, if silence and peaceful protest causes madhav nepal to ignore it and continue his game, what is another alternative to halting everything, creating a bang, and alerting or throwing away madhav nepal ?
It is clear that Maoist don't want to go to jungle anymore.... they just want SATTA.........and u damn YCLs aru lai tharkai tharkai khaney bani basyo
U guys are useless to youth force ... dont blame on politicians only...get ur azz off and work as we people do (u r not Nepali janta....u r ragat chusney chor)
Just MAoists are doing a mistake, they understand all things, but they are creating bang in peoples workplace, houses and business. Actually they should create bang in madhav nepal’s PM quarter and halt his business and if needed, living and life. LEt the foods not enter his quarter, let the cars and people not enter or exit his quarter a. I really doubt if Maoists have got that guts as well.. No one stands for people, they are standing against people and not against the villians like madhav nepal or Bhim Rawals.
Y r u so interested in creating BANG........Banduk ley samasya samadhaan huncha bhanney sochai is totally wrong
U guys are like tanga wala ghoda .... u just look atraight .. dont care what is happening in the surrounding ... and dont want to know urself
Nepal aama ko ragat chusney timiharu ko kahiley pani kalyaan hudaina
JAY NEPAL
Deva May 10, 2010
I thought that this article by Kunda Dixit was quite balanced and displayed his sincere concern for basic fundamental rights of an individual, as also the exceses in which the Maoists are presently engaging themselves in - all in the pretext of fighting for the "People". Kunda's attitude during the the anti monarchy period was lopsided and did not reflect any degree of wisdom as his entire approach was aimed at appeasing the Maoists.
It is not Kunda Dixit I have a grudge against, but people like Kundan Dixit, Padma Ratna Tuladhar, Devendra Raj Pandey, Krishna Pahadi, and Daman Nath Dhungana and the likes, who are very conspicuous by their absence in upholding basic human rights and individual freedom issues. It just shows how false their previous positions were. Shame on you people!
The Maoists are attempting to hide their guilt by shouting against the people of the Valley. They are attempting to raise the morale of their grass root workers by bombastic claims and vicious verbal broadsides. This in the long run will work against them. They have been exposed and will be further isolated from the people. We should however be careful lest we help in propelling another Pol Pot, Stalin, or Hitler from the Himalayas!
Deva
annie May 10, 2010
Well the bandha has been stopped, due to the Maoist feeling for the Nepali people.
Their concern is a bit late!!!!!
Their peaceful strike, is still " VERY PEACEFUL".
I read about the nine year old boy they bashed for riding a bike, who was in need of medical attention after they finished. I am sure this nine year old was a terrible threat to them! Shame, shame , shame.
I read about the woman taken to Pokhara hospital, where she gave birth to a healthy child, but due to the strike could not return home. The child and mother had to live on the street outside the hospital for three days, begging for food, before finally being allowed to go home. This mother and child must have also been a huge threat to the Maoist movement.Shame, shame, shame.
People of this world must be wondering what is happening in Nepal. They will be too afraid to venture there because of all the unrest in the last years.
Pity, because they will miss the beauty of the country and the "Real" beauty of it's people.
May gods bless the true and peaceful Nepali
ASHI May 10, 2010
i wonder where kundan dixit was when emmergency was declared in nepal and we had to wait for 3 days to reach 100kms from the valley..where was dixit when the military harrassed the local passengers in the highway, where was dixit when the ROYAL ARMY was entering people's house at 2 oclock in the morning...so much for ur PEACE THEORY PAL...Are you an ESCAPIST or wat???you seem to be a populist, for you want to sell your article by acting smarties on current issues.
commericla WRITING...nothing else..go start writing for a fashion magazine..
tenzing lama May 11, 2010
like maubadis mr kunda and the himal media are the same.. bfore mr kunda wrote in favor of the maubadis and now after the vandalism and personal loss/vengeance mr kunda decided to write against maubadis... please write what is actually happening in nepal .. personal feelings in this profession is totally unacceptable.. and being a writer please make your stand...as for us these articles are the only form of connection and explanation as to what is happening back in nepal.. so please .. respect your profession and relate to us as to what is actually going on in nepal and what seems to be the intention...
Shubhanga Pandey May 11, 2010
Dr Neupane,
I would love to see examples of " grossly illusory and amblyopic vision" in the article. Could you please locate some specific instances?
Also I fail to see any philosophical meanderings in the blog. I would infer that his was a genuine inability to reconcile his understanding of "peaceful protest" with the popular labeling of this protest as "peaceful and non-violent". I hope to see a factual refutation and not a ideological defense.
Thanks