Rewinding to 1999 and the piece ‘Can the South Asian Toad Leapfrog’ was a sobering reminder of just how fast technology is moving forward, even in our part of the developing world. Himal Southasian carried this version in its online edition on 5 August, 2013.
It was nice joke 13 years ago to say: “90% of Indians are waiting for phones, and 5% are waiting for dial tones.” Look at where we are now: the number of Indians with mobile phones is about to cross the 1 billion mark. In November 2012, the number of people in India who accessed the Internet through their smart phones and tablets exceeded the number of people who accessed it through their PCs or laptops.
In that article in 1999, I poked fun at a minister who said India should graduate from making potato chips to making microchips. I ridiculed Bill Gates and his remark that India could “leapfrog” into the future by turning Bangalore into the digital sweatshop of the Internet age. Today, Gates himself has been left trailing behind by embarrassingly young internet billionaires who have adapted to the new mobility that the Internet has been provided with the spread of i-Phones, Androids and other smart phones.
When that article appeared in Himal in 1999, I was making a living being a cyber-sceptic. Before talking about levelling the playing field, I argued, it was important to ensure there was a playing field. Before sticking a computer into a classroom, we should first make sure it has a roof. Or electricity. Or text books. Or qualified teachers. Or that the school-children are not stunted because they don’t have enough to eat. We were being carried away by a technology that promised to set everything right overnight. We actually believed that convergence would change the world.
But the coming together of telephony, computers and television has actually changed the world, whether we like it or not. We may have doubts about whether the transformation in the way we communicate will make a difference, but the speed of the spread of communication technologies has metamorphosed society. The medium is the message, in a way Marshall McLuhan probably never imagined. It is the end of geography.
The moment of truth came to me in 2010 on a mountaintop in a remote part of northwestern Nepal, a week’s walk away from the nearest road. I had just got myself my first smartphone through which I took some fairly decent images of the stunning scenery of a crystal blue lake spread out below me with the snow mountain beyond. I could transmit that picture out immediately into the worldwide web through Twitter, Facebook and email. Suddenly, here was a technology that was immediate, and which could magnify and extend the journalists’ reach way beyond what old timers like me thought was possible.
Since that epiphany on the mount, I have become a born again proponent of the potential of the new information and communication technologies for transforming society. I am not yet fully convinced about where all this hype and obsession with bandwidth, speed, the breathlessness of social networking sites is going, and I doubt if it will solve problems of governance, equity and delivery of basic services to the poorest in poor countries. After all, the district of Mugu from where I transmitted that picture into the Net is still the poorest in Nepal where four times more children die before their fifth birth day than the national average. But it has telecom towers.
Even so, I am now convinced about the Internet’s ability to transform at least journalism. Indeed, it already has. There are examples from around the world that information can empower. Ease of communications opens up doors for business, cuts out middlemen, and lessens the transaction costs of trade. The vast corpus of knowledge stored and archived on the Net has also changed the way people around the world access knowledge. Crowdsourcing has made the whole process more participatory, with built-in capacity for self-correction. Falsehoods don’t have a long shelf-life in the Net, as the Wiki effect allows the public to correct mistakes.
The challenge now is to ensure that the information available on the Net is available to those who need it the most to catch up. Information does not necessarily spread knowledge, informed people are not necessarily wiser. The latest scientific information on tuberculosis is all over the Internet: how to prevent it, which therapies work, the antibiotics that bacilli have become resistant to. But this information needs to get where it is needed as cheaply as possible, it needs to be relevant to the needs of the people it is meant for, and it must be packaged so that it is easily understood. In South Asian countries, where most people die of communicable diseases the first line of defence must be communication of preventive measures, and awareness generation about causes. Is it absolutely necessary to spread that knowledge through Google search, or is old fashioned radio more effective?
To be useful, information must help people communicate, participate and allow them and their rulers to make informed choices. Recognition of the power of knowledge may be as old as civilisation, but what is different now is the speed and capacity to move that information. At present, this speed and capacity are concentrated in the same countries in which wealth and power are concentrated. The global spread of mobile phones has proved that the technology has the capacity to leapfrog, now we just have to make sure that the message we are communicating will help improve lives.
After all, the corporate and political structures that governed the current Knowledge Revolution are the same ones that governed the Industrial Revolution. The main impact of e-commerce, in fact, is felt in the same old consumerism, allowing access to digital mail-order catalogues with online payment and global home delivery. We have just added the ‘e-’ prefix to commerce.


