A month into his prime ministership Balendra Shah, who is also handling the Defence and Home Ministry protfolios, sent in security forces on a massive demolition drive of squatter settlements along Kathmandu’s riverbanks.
He had tried to do this as mayor of Kathmandu, but had been thwarted by protests and obstruction by the UML-Congress-Maoist coalitions. As a prime minister who leads a near two-third majority, he has more power now to raze what he sees are strongholds of the legacy parties.
Public reaction is mixed. A fierce propaganda battle is raging in cybersphere between pro-Balen content creators who praise the prime minister’s decisiveness and ridicule fake squatters who own property, and those who see it as a gross violation of human rights.
The government says it is identifying the ‘genuinely landless’ and will relocate them. But reporters say police forced them to delete images of families in flimsy shelters taking cover from Wednesday evening’s storm.
Before the election, the RSP’s Rabi Lamichhane had said the would stand between a bulldozer and the genuine landless if they were evicted. But Prime Minister Shah did not make any distinction when he issued his orders to level settlements this week.
Shah is said to have acted on the squatters without consultation within his party or with the local government.
“The ethos of this government seems to be move fast and break things, but that's not how an elected government works, says analyst Ashutosh Tiwari. “They don't have to do everything in 100 days.”
Critics and activists have questioned why the political leadership chose to begin with demolishing settlements before identifying, relocating and providing alternatives for landless Nepalis.
“The issue of landless Nepalis is tied to housing, employment, discrimination, poverty— it is a microcosm of everything that is wrong in Nepal,” says Tiwari. “The government was able to evict the people safely compared to the last time this happened in Kathmandu, but the decisions made were after the fact and ad hoc, and showed immaturity, haste, and a lack of understanding of complex issues.”
The Prime Minister now wants to take his demolition drive nationwide to squatter settlements along highways and national parks, and has even instructed the Nepal Army to collect data.
For critics, the prime minister is still acting as if he is mayor and pursuing showcase urban beautification as visible proof of his resoluteness in order to appeal to the middle class.
Says political scientist Sucheta Pyakuryal: “A politically mature and administratively well-versed government would not have begun with dismantling before having proper plans and programs in place to accommodate the poor, these actions do not speak very well of this leadership.”
She adds, “The state is everybody’s agency, and it is up to the state to protect the fundamental rights of all Nepalis.”
PM Shah’s decision to unleash bulldozers on slums is symptomatic of a deeper ideological dichotomy — not just between the leaders of the party, but also between the RSP’s own electoral platforms.
There have been other puzzling decisions. Provisions of a draft NRN Bill does not deliver on the RSP’s progressive election pledges and has angered overseas Nepalis who had mobilised support for the party in the election.
The RSP manifesto promised citizenship by descent, and friendlier economic and investment provision, and streamlining the NRN card process. But the proposed draft does not seem to make any mention of citizenship, and includes a one-house ownership limit as well as a 50% tax on the sale of inherited ancestral property.

