A new draft counter-intelligence bill is raising fears that Big Government wants to constrict constitutionally-guaranteed freedom of expression and individual privacy.
This comes even as the UML-NC coalition is trying to push through the Media Council Bill that would increase government interference in the media.
The counter-intelligence bill harks back to the Panchayat absolute monarchy days and also 2014-15 when a repressive anti-corruption agency listened in on citizens and tracked them.
The government says the National Intelligence Act is outdated because of advances in private messaging apps with end-to-end encryption, and needs to be regulated. But after the Prime Minister’s Office released a draft, it has sparked debate even before reaching Parliament.
Civil rights activists have particular objection to a provision in the Bill for ‘interception’ — allowing authorities to monitor, surveil, or record communications, audio, video, or electronic signals from suspected individuals or organisations.
Section 15 of the draft bill states: ‘…If it is not possible to collect information through other means, and if immediate collection of such information is necessary to prevent serious harm to the country, the Inspector General of Police, upon being convinced, may issue a written order to any officer under their direct supervision to monitor or surveil communications, audio, video, or electronic signals or data from any suspected individual, organisation, or institution, or to intercept and record such information.’
Such surveillance is deemed necessary for ‘internal and external intelligence and investigative work and to protect and promote the country’s independence, sovereignty, territorial integrity, national security, national interest, unity, and autonomy’.
Experts say such a provision could be misused as has happened in the recent past when such unchecked authority falls into the wrong hands.
“It is not that such powers should not exist, but other safeguards are necessary which are missing in this draft,” argues constitutional expert Bipin Adhikari, adding that these should include safeguards against the blatant and arbitrary misuse of surveillance powers.
Read also: Spooking Nepalis by snooping on them, Mukesh Pokhrel
During the investigation into the murder of Acting Supreme Court Justice Ran Bahadur Bam in 2012, the police collected call details from 500,000 mobile phones and 30,000 SMS messages. Many of the messages that were unrelated to the investigation were reportedly used by officers for entertainment, with sexual content being the most widely shared. This was exposed by an investigation in Kantipur with the headline एसएमएस अरूले हेर्लान् नि! (Others might see your SMS!).
In 2016, a motion for impeachment was filed in Parliament against Lokman Singh Karki, the vicious head of the Commission for the Investigation of Abuse of Authority (CIAA). Although he was appointed by the same politicians who wanted him out, one of the reasons for the move was Karki’s abuse of surveillance powers, including phone tapping and spying on political leaders, security officials, judges, civil society leaders, journalists, and administrative officers. The phones of 293 individuals were later found to have been tapped.

