Alton C Byers is a mountain geographer, conservationist and researcher on Himalayan glaciers with the Institute for Arctic and Alpine Research at the University of Colorado, Boulder. Sophia Kalantzakos of New York University's Geopolitics and Ecology of Himalayan Waters Initiative spoke to him about this week’s Himalayan flood disaster.
Sophia Kalantzakos: You've been warning about this kind of catastrophic flood for years. What exactly happened on the China-Nepal border on 26 August?
Alton Byers: We're getting more and more insights. What we can say for sure is that this is different from your classic glacial lake outburst flood. What we had was a massive breakage of ice and rock from high on Langtang Lirung on the Nepal side of the border with Tibet. It plummeted down and, in effect, was the catalyst for a series of cascading events. I think that the breakage was related to changes in permafrost, which has become vulnerable to warming trends. Permafrost was the cryosphere glue that held these mountains together for millennia, and we're seeing more massive breakages of snow and ice and rock as well. I've seen rock faces the size of the Empire State Building calve off.
As it falls, friction at that velocity melts the ice. It hits the ground below. Hurricane-force winds level trees. All this then went into the Bhote Kosi, blocked the river and then you got this horrendous release of millions of cubic meters of water.
I've been monitoring such events since at least 2012, and the Seti Flood in the Pokhara region had almost the exact same sequence of events, and there have been a dozen others since then.
There was no warning, was it something that could have been predicted for this particular area?
Yeah, it happens very quickly, just a matter of hours or less from the initial breakage to the creation of what they call a hyper-concentrated slurry flood. Imagine liquid concrete flowing down the river, carrying boulders the size of houses. You can't really predict these, but you can identify areas of risk from remote sensing, you can see mountains that have similar overhanging ice, and you can make the logical assumption that they would be more prone to breakage than others.
But really, the critical point, and that I'm starting to hear more and more on this in the Nepal press, is that there are settlements along floodplains. A tremendous surge in unregulated, unplanned urbanisation, with much of the building along the rivers where it really shouldn't be. If you look at aerial photos from 50 years ago, you'll see that the villages in the area were up high. Only farms may have been down by the river because that's where a lot of fertile soil is. So this is unfortunately a consequence of building in the wrong places.

Why was there so much debris, rubble, and boulders coming down the mountain?
It's rugged to begin with, it's vertical, it's an extremely dynamic environment. As mountains build, they also erode, and erosion takes the form of everything from soil loss to avalanches, to debris flows, to landslides, with a lot of stored material from past floods. So, when you get a new one, the new flood picks up this older material in addition to everything that it's bringing down.
These are terrifying events. I've interviewed people who say they sound like someone moaning in agony. It sloshes back and forth along the river, and can go up to 100 metres when it comes around the corner. And the smell is like gunpowder, probably because rocks are hitting each other and sparking. The footage from this flood is the most horrific I have ever seen. This was by far the largest.
How should the media frame this story? Is this related to climate change?
That is the number one question. And they want to know what kind of flood it was, they want to know how it happened. It's a pretty complex process, and it's something that we really haven't been that aware of. Changes in the permafrost are relatively new to most scientists. I do have colleagues who have been studying it for 20 or 30 years like Wilfried Haberle of the University of Bern. He and I wrote a piece for the Nepali Times a year ago on what the paper called the ‘not-so-permanent permafrost’. In other words, it's changing too. The main triggering events of this cascading process are almost identical to previous floods that I've studied. We will not know the causes for days or weeks or months, because it takes time. For now, we're directing our energy to rescue. That's where they should be.


