
As usual, a flight from the Gulf to Kathmandu one evening this week was full of returning migrant workers. The excitement in the cabin was palpable. Passengers peered out of the window as Himalayan peaks on the horizon drew nearer.
A passenger on the aisle seat works in a café in Dubai and was coming home after 2 years. A taxi driver from Abu Dhabi had not seen his new-born daughter, and was coming home with enough savings to build a new house. A bar manager connecting from a flight from London was returning for her annual vacation, and going to Pokhara to get married.
As they stepped off, some knelt to finger the tarmac and touch their foreheads as a mark of respect for the motherland. There was loud chatter on the ramp bus, and even the long queue at the health check that stretched out into the apron was not enough to diminish the enthusiasm.
Nepal’s media commentators express shock that 630,089 labour approvals were issued in 2021/22, and highlight the departure concourse at Kathmandu airport as a symbol of citizens failed by their country. But here in the arrival section of the airport in the same year, 470,978 workers returned to Nepal.
The financial remittances and economic exposure they come home with are, however, not being leveraged for sustained wellbeing of their families and the national economy.
Nepal’s new government has a unique chance to adopt a bold new worker-centred approach to streamline the migrant labour sector. The bar has been set low by previous governments, so if the new coalition cannot help, it should at least do no harm.
After all, migrant worker rights played an important role in building support for former tv anchor Rabi Lamichhane when he decided to enter politics. Today, as Chair of the independent Rastriya Swatantra Party (RSP), he is Home Minister and Deputy Prime Minister, playing a key role in the 7-party coalition government of Prime Minister Pushpa Kamal Dahal.
Lamichhane’s सिधा कुरा जनतासंग (Straight Talk with Citizens) was a television program that many migrant workers in distress reached out to when stranded abroad, or were duped by recruiters.
When unanswered embassy calls are the norm, and the government fails to stay digitally connected with its dispersed citizens abroad, making himself approachable even as a journalist mattered to Lamichhane.
Which is why it made sense that his party got the labour portfolio, presenting an opportunity for Nepal’s migrant worker community that has been yearning for reform. But questions have also been raised about the RSP's commitment to integrity and good governance ever since Lamichhane got himself appointed as Minister of Home Affairs. He will be heading a ministry that was probing his controversial citizenship matter.
RSP's appointment of Dol Prasad Aryal as Minister for Labour, Employment and Social Service has also raised concerns about conflict of interest due to his reported links to recruitment firms and a remittance company.
Aryal has denied it, and his supporters have given him the benefit of doubt, saying it may be better than past labour ministers from mainstream parties who were clueless about how overseas migration works, and (what's worse) were in the payroll of recruiters. Besides, there will be watchdogs within his RSP who could keep him in check.
The RSP’s stance on foreign employment is to forge a society in which Nepalis are not forced to migrate (“रोजगारीका लागि बाध्यतावश देश छोड्नु नपर्ने समाजको परिकल्पना गर्दछौ”). Its policies focus on a one-stop shop for migrant workers, investment incentives for productive use of remittances, diversification of overseas work, higher skilled opportunities, reintegrating returnee migrant workers, and rapid response arrangements for those in distress.
These are all reasonable goals, and ones we have heard before in past pledges by previous governments. What Nepalis always needed was implementation of those promises. After all, the RSP’s stunning victory in the November 2022 elections was partly due to its commitment to do things differently, and to get things done. This is what voters are hoping for.
And getting things done in emigration requires bolder and more innovative interventions than what we have been accustomed to. Regulation and facilitation are both needed in a balanced approach. What we hear a lot in the media is call for regulation, and that is because corruption and political patronage have made it weak. Facilitation, for its part, has never been a priority.
Over 90% of Nepali workers abroad (except India) are handled by the private sector. Recruiters serve an important function of matching workers with overseas jobs, but they are mired in unhealthy, fierce competition, not just among themselves, but also with agencies in other countries competing to procure job orders.
Getting job orders, any type of job with a disregard to employment terms, and at any cost (given assurances that workers will pay) has been the norm -- as many Nepali workers in the Gulf related recently. Cases of migrants getting duped by recruiters or those who pretend to be recruiters are far too common.
It is a national disgrace that migrant workers who are desperate to improve their lives, suffer as a result. The public has pinned its hope on the RSP to boldly regulate the migrant labour sector with integrity, and prevent swindlers and fraudsters to manipulate decisions. It may help that Rabi Lamichhane is also Minister for Home Affairs.
To deliver practical results, however, the private sector needs to be involved since there are 880 ‘manpower’ agencies which have enabled millions of Nepalis to become good providers for their families back home.
How else would a worker in a village in Dhanusha or Banke who has never left his village, or is not technologically savvy, find employment at a Dubai-based company? How will they ever navigate the layers of bureaucracy imposed by the government and kickbacks every step of the way?
This intermediary role of the recruiting agency is vital, and we cannot wish it away. The trouble is that it gets obscured in the daily media bombardment of dire experiences of migrants being exploited, hoodwinked or abused.

A genuinely bold strategy focused on migrant worker welfare could make the overseas labour intermediation sector more professional so it can operate like any other human resource entity, providing a critical transnational job-matching function.
Recruiters are often notorious for cheating workers, but usually it is that a share of the “pie” has to be set aside for politicians, party cadres and bureaucrats up the food chain. As per the law, they deposit high escrow amounts and have to clear many bureaucratic hurdles that complicate and delay their departure of migrant workers they send, which can annoy their clients overseas, who are employers.
The practical challenges facing the recruitment industry are immense because the process is international, it is fueled by desperation and aspiration, competition from within and beyond Nepal’s borders, with tens of thousands of intermediaries, as well as negotiations with foreign employers who themselves are looking for ways to minimise costs.
What we are missing are actual interventions to make the migrant labour sector more streamlined and transparent. There is a lot of lip service about reforming recruitment practices, lofty principles are bandied about with non-binding, soft commitments and moralism that mean little in practice. Interventions are far removed from the ground reality, but they need to start where we are, not where we need to ideally be.
Good recruiters can market themselves better to attract the best employers with strong employment practices. If not, 'manpowers' will continue to resort to ‘buying job demands’ from employers which can include companies that do not take good care of hired workers.
Job agencies respond better to the labour and recruitment standards set by employers in ways they do not feel accountable to the government, the public or the policies in place, as what really matters to them is their bottom line.
Among all the bad apples in the recruitment industry there are also good apples trying to do things better. But not much has been done to help them even if such initiatives go counter to prevailing populist narratives that generalise. All recruiters are tarred with the same brush, and a perfunctory call for more regulatory action is made. How will more regulation help when regulators are a part of the problem? The government needs to use not just sticks, but also carrots.
There is disproportionate coverage in the Nepali media, social media and public discourse of negative migration stories. That in itself is a topic worth studying, as it affects our attitude towards emigration.
Foreign employment has allowed scores of migrant workers to overcome odds stacked against them, but perhaps not in newsworthy ways. A story of a sting operation will get much more media attention and readership than profiles of workers who went to the Gulf and came back with savings, skills and with a network of contacts.
Foreign employment has its faults but it has also changed the lives of workers like Hom, Krishna and Suresh who have been featured in the Diaspora Diaries series in Nepali Times in the past two years. Many of those who are profiled started with nothing, they charted out their own futures thanks to foreign employment.
The discourse in the Nepali public sphere victimises migrant workers even when it is not needed. Case in point: when Nepali migrant workers in the Gulf rallied to send oxygen cylinders home during the Covid pandemic, the media and the social web were full of stories about ‘poor migrant workers who skipped their meals to send oxygen to Nepal’.
Nepali workers abroad themselves were not happy with such exaggerated framing of their collective effort. It is possible to acknowledge the immense contribution migrant workers make or push for labour reforms without always portraying them as helpless sufferers.
It may be time for Nepali journalists, researchers and commentators to also step back and assess how such coverage affects the way society regards emigration, and how this impacts on migration governance.

